|
http://www.ucsusa.org/index.html
ALERT: ENERGY
BILL (HR 4) ON HOUSE FLOOR - CONTACT YOUR REPRESENTATIVE
Thursday morning, August 2nd,
the House of Representatives will begin floor debate on an energy bill that is a
giant step - BACKWARD. The House has taken this, the first opportunity in a
decade to address US energy policy, and used it to fashion a bill that gives us
more of the same old, same old. Rather than offering a vision of an
energy supply produced with healthy portions from efficiency and clean
renewables - a vision suited to the 21st Century - this energy bill is
chock-full of policies and tax breaks that were bad ideas back in the
1970s. With a long list of giveaways to the oil, gas, and nuclear
industries, and only modest incentives for renewable sources of energy, this
bill is very much out of balance.
This bill would:
-- Allow drilling in
the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) and
other
pristine wilderness areas;
-- Legislate a miniscule improvement, about a mile per
gallon, in the
overall
fuel economy of vehicles sold in the US;
-- Continue and enlarge subsidies for the nuclear and fossil
fuel industries;
-- Provide new
incentives for the construction of so-called "Clean Coal" power plants;
-- Offer only modest support for
energy efficiency and some renewable energy technologies;
-- Do little to address global
climate change.
PLEASE
CONTACT YOUR REPRESENTATIVE and tell him or her that, unless there are
significant changes in this bill (HR 4), it is unacceptable. If this
bill is not dramatically altered, it is better that it be defeated outright.
ACTION: Urge your Representative to:
* Support an amendment
that would prevent drilling in the pristine Arctic National Wildlife Refuge.
* Support the Boehlert-Markey
amendment on Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) standards;
* Support the Inslee-Shays amendment
that would cut subsidies to fossil fuel and nuclear technologies and increase
incentives for renewable energy and energy efficiency;
* Support amendments that will
require a Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) and a Public Benefits Trust Fund
(PBTF)
TIMING: THIS WEEK - the
vote could happen as soon as Thursday, August 2nd.
HOW TO CONTACT:
To contact your
Representative by phone, call the Capitol switchboard, (202) 225-3121, and ask
to be put through to his/her office. You can also send a personal
note via fax.
To obtain e-mail
addresses, go to www.house.gov.
If you don't know who your Representative is, you can find
out at www.house.gov/writerep.
QUESTIONS: If you have questions about this
action alert, please contact either Thomas Boyle or Ron Sundergill in UCS's
Washington, DC office by responding to this email or by calling 202.223.6133.
**********
GUIDELINES FOR E-MAILING MEMBERS OF CONGRESS
When sending email, follow
these guidelines:
-- Never
forward our Action alerts to congressional offices. Always use the
information in our alerts to write your own message.
-- Ask for a reply to your email message and check to make
sure you receive a response, since some offices do not yet have a system for
handling constituent email. If you do not receive a reply within a
reasonable time period, call the office to see if they received your message.
-- Use the format of a letter
for your email message, including your return address to verify you are a
constituent. Without a return address, your message could be severely
discounted or simply be deleted.
**********
NOTE: If you send a letter, a fax, or an email, please send
us a "blind copy." (A blind copy simply means that you do not indicate anywhere
on your letter that you are sending a copy to us.) By email, send to
energyintern@ucsusa.org.
CHANGE
OF EMAIL ADDRESS: Help us keep you posted! If your email address will soon
change, or if you'd like us to use a different address, please let us know by
sending a message to ucs@ucsusa.org with your new address. Thanks!
**********
TALKING POINTS/BACKGROUND
ANWR: Having access to the Arctic
National Wildlife Refuge has been a dream of the petroleum industry for
decades. But the amount of oil estimated by the USGS to be
economically recoverable from ANWR is what the United States uses in about six
months. Any oil found in ANWR would do nothing to lower prices or
promote American energy independence. Oil is a global commodity and
will follow the highest price.
CAFE: The fuel economy of America's fleet of cars and trucks
is at its lowest point in 20 years. Increasing fuel economy is an
essential part of decreasing air pollution, global warming emissions, and
America's dependence on oil. The bill's current provision on fuel
economy could result in savings of 5 billion gallons of gasoline from light
trucks by 2010. That may sound like a lot, but it is the equivalent
of raising the fuel economy of light trucks (SUVs, pick-ups, minivans) by less
than 1 mile per gallon and amounts to saving 1 days worth of oil per
year. It is an attempt to block real change through minimal and
counterproductive revisions to current federal fuel economy
standards.
Reps.
Markey (D-MA) and Boehlert (R-NY) will be offering a reasonable alternative to
the do-next-to-nothing approach. Their amendment would close the
loophole that allows SUVs, pick-ups and minivans to have a lower fuel economy
standard than cars. Cars and trucks would have to meet a 27.5 mile
per gallon average by 2007.
SUBSIDIES TO THE FOSSIL FUEL AND NUCLEAR INDUSTRIES:
The bill provides $26.8 billion in tax breaks over 10 years,
of which at least 75 percent, or $19 billion, is for fossil fuels and nuclear
energy. This is even more than President Bush proposed in his energy
plan.
This energy bill is full
of tax incentives and subsidies for exploration and production of oil and gas
despite the fact that the petroleum mega-corporations are enjoying record
profits.
There is $6 billion
worth of subsidies for the coal industry, including incentives to encourage the
generation of electricity with "Clean Coal" technologies. However,
there is no such thing as "Clean Coal," only "Somewhat Less Dirty
Coal." The federal government has already spent some $2 billion on
"Somewhat Less Dirty Coal" technologies with little to show for
it. Despite almost twenty years of research, there are only a handful
of demonstration projects of these technologies. None are in
commercial use because the electricity they produce is so
expensive. During those same twenty years, the cost of electricity
generated from wind has gone down by more than half.
ENERGY EFFICIENCY:
The bill codifies
the Bush Administration's rollback of efficiency standards for air conditioners.
RENEWABLE PORTFOLIO STANDARD:
An RPS is an essential and modest first step in leveling
the playing field for renewables. All emerging technologies
require sustained investment to become viable in a competitive
marketplace. This is even more the case with renewable energy
technologies designed to generate electricity for commercial sale to the grid,
since fossil fuel and nuclear generation have received and continue to receive a
tremendous amount in taxpayer investment and subsidies.
The RPS is not itself a
subsidy. Rather, it is a market-driven mechanism designed to offer
maximum flexibility and efficiency in implementation. Its purpose is
to help market-ready renewable energy technologies compete on a playing field
that will continue to be far from level even with the RPS.
Under the RPS, all sellers of
electricity would be required to demonstrate that an established percentage of
their annual generation represents renewable energy sources: wind, solar,
biomass, geothermal, and organic waste - excluding incinerated municipal
waste. (Hydroelectric power is not included as a renewable source
since it is a mature technology.) The percentage should start at 2.5%
in 2002 and level out at 20% in 2020. No specific technologies or
renewable sources are mandated. Power sellers make all the decisions
about how to comply. They may acquire credits either by generating
renewable energy themselves, or, if it is cheaper, by buying credits for
renewable energy generated by other producers. Thus, the energy is
produced in the most economically efficient manner.
PUBLIC BENEFITS TRUST FUND:
Another
way of preserving the public benefits of renewable energy and energy efficiency
is to create a direct funding mechanism. Public benefits funding can
be provided from fees placed on electricity companies or
customers. Such fees are sometimes referred to as "system benefit
charges" and are analogous to funding mechanisms created during both
long-distance telephone and airline deregulation. A fee on
long-distance calls, for example, helps to preserve universal telephone
service. A surcharge on all airline tickets helps support airport
maintenance and air traffic control. Public benefits funding also
covers energy efficiency programs, research and development, universal service,
and other low-income protections.
Such a direct funding mechanism has some unique advantages
for preserving the public benefits of clean energy. First, funds can
be allocated where they are likely to be most effective. For example,
they can be directed toward technologies that have great long-run potential,
like solar photovoltaics (PV), but that will not be immediately competitive even
with other renewables. These technologies will have a difficult time
competing for market share even with a Renewables Portfolio
Standard. On a state level, funding can be targeted toward resources
that provide special benefits to that state. For example, a state
with excellent solar resources or with many PV manufacturing companies could
target more of its funding to PV. A state with wind resources could
use the fund for wind resource assessment, collaborative projects to identify
and overcome obstacles to siting or permitting, or directly for wind project
development.
To: All Activists
From: Alix
Davidson, American Lands Recreation Campaigner
Help Stop Bush
Rollback of Yellowstone Snowmobile Ban
Please ask your Representative to sign the Holt (D,
NJ)- Gilchrest (R,
MD) letter to protest the rollback of
the Yellowstone Snowmobile
Decision- letter closes on
August 3rd. You can reach your Reps at the
congressional switchboard number which is
202/224-3121.
Yellowstone
National Park was in the middle of transitioning from
uncontrolled personal snowmobile use to mass-transit
snowcoaches, after completing an
EIS and receiving
65,000 public comments which overwhelmingly supported the
snowmobile ban. Due to a lawsuit by the
snowmobile industry, the Bush
Administration has decided
halt the phase out of snowmobiles and reopen
the
process. Please read the below letter from Representatives Holt and
Gilchrest and ask your Representatives to sign onto the
letter.
Please contact
Alix Davidson at (202) 547-5974 or at
adavidson@americanlands.org if you have any questions.
SUPPORT CONSERVATION
SUPPORT THE
AMERICAN MAJORITY
OPPOSE A
ROLLBACK OF THE
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE DECISION
ON YELLOWSTONE SNOWMOBILES
July 18, 2001
Dear Colleague:
We are writing to ask you to join us
in sending the letter on the back
to President Bush,
expressing concern about his Administration's
decision
to reopen the decision of the National Park Service (NPS) to
phase out snowmobile use in Yellowstone and Grand Teton
national parks.
The NPS decision
was based on years of scientific study and was, the
Service concluded, necessary to comply with the NPS Organic
Act and
rules adopted by President Nixon and the Reagan
Administration on
snowmobile use in national
parks. Before making its decision, the NPS
held 22 public meetings and considered 65,000
comments. A Zogby poll
this spring concluded
that 66 percent of the American people support the
Yellowstone rule - with 46 percent strongly supporting
it.
Please join us
in standing up for America's national parks. If you have
any questions, or if you wish to cosign the letter, please
contact
Stephen Saunders in the Holt office, at
225-5801, or Sally McGee in the
Gilchrest office, at
225-5311 by August 3.
Sincerely,
______________________________________________________
Rush Holt Wayne Gilchrest
Steve Holmer
Campaign Coordinator
American Lands
726 7th Street SE
Washington, D.C. 20003
202/547-9105
202/547-9213 fax
mailto:wafcdc@americanlands.org
http://www.americanlands.org
------------------------------------------------
EARTHJUSTICE E-BRIEF
Monthly news
and views from Earthjustice Legal Defense Fund
------------------------------------------------
In this issue:
> DONATE YOUR TAX REBATE
> SUPPORT NEW SOURCE REVIEW & CLEAN AIR
> ROADLESS FOREST INITIATIVE NEEDS YOUR VOICE
> RECENT VICTORIES
> JOIN THE
ACTIVIST NETWORK
> ABOUT EARTHJUSTICE
------------------------------------------------
DONATE YOUR TAX REBATE…
BECAUSE THE
BUSH ADMINISTRATION IS TAXING THE ENVIRONMENT
The Bush
Justice Department isn’t defending our environmental laws, so
donate your rebate to the people who will – Earthjustice!
(Your gift will
be DOUBLED by a matching grant.) We’ll
use your rebate to safeguard our
natural treasures and
the laws that protect them.
http://www.earthjustice.org/rebate
------------------------------------------------
SUPPORT NEW SOURCE REVIEW & CLEAN AIR – by July 27
The Bush administration's energy plan calls for
reconsideration of the New
Source Review, a cornerstone
of the Clean Air Act that has reduced toxic
emissions.
It requires industrial facilities to curtail air pollution when
modifying their plants. Tell the EPA not to allow the Bush
administration
to trade public health for corporate
wealth. Send comments by the end of
this week!
http://ga0.org/campaign/toxic_two_step
------------------------------------------------
ROADLESS FOREST INITIATIVE NEEDS YOUR VOICE
The Bush administration is trying to overturn January’s
Roadless Area
Conservation Rule, one of the most
important conservation initiatives ever
undertaken to
protect America's public lands. You can help protect 58
million acres of pristine national forests by registering
your comments
with the U.S. Forest Service before
September 10.
http://ga0.org/campaign/roadless_comments
------------------------------------------------
RECENT VICTORIES
> JUDGE HALTS ARMY TRAINING AT MAKUA
Earthjustice successfully worked with Hawai'ian group Malama
Makau to
prove that live-fire training exercises at
Makua Military Reservation on
O`ahu should not be
allowed until a comprehensive Environmental Impact
Statement is conducted.
http://www.earthjustice.org/news/display.html?ID=212
> WESTERN LANDS PROTECTED
At the end of June, the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance
and Earthjustice
convinced a federal judge that heavy
construction for jeep roads in Grand
Staircase-Escalante
National Monument was in violation of R.S. 2477, the
“right of way” law. This ruling will positively affect the
uses of federal
lands throughout the West.
http://www.earthjustice.org/news/display.html?ID=202
------------------------------------------------
WANT TO BE AN EARTHJUSTICE ACTIVIST?
Help enforce laws on clean air and water, national forests,
endangered
species, and more. Join the Earthjustice
Action Center and you’ll receive
regular Action alerts
in your e-mail box.
http://www.earthjustice.org/action
------------------------------------------------
ABOUT EARTHJUSTICE
Founded as the
Sierra Club Legal Defense Fund in 1971, Earthjustice Legal
Defense Fund is the non-profit law firm for the environment.
Earthjustice
represents hundreds of environmental
organizations, large and small, from
nine offices across
the country. We do not charge our clients for our
services.
SUPPORT US
Your support of
Earthjustice will help defend and protect our forests and
other public lands; our air, water, and wildlife; our
children, and our
communities. Please, join us.
http://www.earthjustice.org/support/
QUESTIONS? FEEDBACK?
Drop us a line: mailto:enews@earthjustice.org
------------------------------------------------
All contents copyright 2001 by Earthjustice Legal Defense
Fund, 180
Montgomery Street, Suite 1400, San Francisco,
CA 94104
The Nature Conservancy's Nature News, August 1, 2001
Save the Birds!
Nearly half of the world's 10,000
bird species breed in the Americas. We wake to their songs, mark the seasons by
their presence and are inspired by their grace.
But the birds of North America, Latin America and the
Caribbean are in trouble. In fact, more than 1,000 species are now in decline or
are dangerously scarce.
Now
there's an easy way for you to help - for free. Just go to The Nature
Conservancy's home page, http://www.you-click.net/GoNow/a14464a38905a67074702a1, look for the bird and click
it. The Nature Valley Company will donate $1 to the Conservancy on
your behalf.
This money will
help protect vital bird habitat. Places like the Edge of Appalachia
Preserve in Ohio and Ecuador's Podocarpus National Park.
Just one click. A pretty easy way to
give our winged friends even more reason to sing, don't you
think?
The Pallone-Saxton-C.Smith amendment which sought an
additional $3 million for beach water monitoring grants
passed the U.S. House of Representatives Monday evening.
With this amendment to the U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency funding bill, the House is recommending a total
of $10 million in beach monitoring grants to coastal
states for next year. These funds will help coastal
states develop and improve beach water quality monitoring
and public information programs. The U.S. Senate will
likely vote on its U.S. EPA funding bill after Labor
Day. We still have a lot of work ahead of us to convince
the U.S. Senate to provide sufficient funding to improve
beach water testing.
Thank you to everyone who called their Congressional
representative last week in support of the
Pallone-Saxton-C.Smith
amendment. Also, thank you to the
hundreds of ocean
activists who consistently respond to
our beach water
action alerts. We will let you know
other key times
to raise your voice for healthy, safe
beaches
LANDSCOPE: News and Views from American Lands Alliance -
August 1, 2001
GAO Testimony
Concludes: Agencies Failing to
Effectively Implement
National Fire Plan
Yesterday the
General Accounting Office (GAO) testified in the House
Forest and Forest Health Subcommittee that there were many
problems with
the Forest Service and Department of
Interior's implementation of the
National Fire
Plan. The GAO was charged by Congress to investigate
whether the money appropriated (almost $3 billion) in Fiscal
Year 2001
is being used effectively and efficiently by
the agency to implement the
National Fire
Plan. The GAO stated that implementation of the National
Fire Plan lacks coordination, consistency and agreement
called for in
the 1995 Federal Wildland Fire
Policy. The highest-risk communities
have not
been identified. And, effective implementation of the National
Fire Plan may require changes to the agencies organizational
structures.
…During the testimony the GAO took issue with the agencies
reluctance to
implement fire management plans and the
agencies failure to act now to
"resolve the
wildland-urban interface problems." The GAO stated that
because there is no prioritization for communities at risk,
the National
Fire Plan wrongly targets forests for fuels
reduction treatments that
are not fire dependent such as
many of the Eastern U.S. Forests. For a
copy of the GAO testimony go to the Forest and Forest Health
Subcommittee's website at
http://resourcescommittee.house.gov/107cong/forests/forest01.htm#2001
Wildfire
Websites: The Western Fire Ecology Center's website
http://www.fire-ecology.org provides valuable
information on current
events, fire policy, research,
public education and gives suggestions
for citizen
action. Scientific information about fire and the
environment is readily accessible through the
site. Similarly, the
Wilderness Society's
site http://www.WildfireCentral.org supplies daily
fire weather forecasts and National Interagency Fire Center
reports,
maps of the largest fires around the country,
information about
individual home protection, and
updates on current wildfire. The U.S.
Department of Agriculture and the U.S. Department of the
Interior site
http://www.fireplan.gov serves as an information
clearinghouse to
provide up-to-date interagency
information and other related details on
the National
Fire Plan. Lee Enterprises and its newspapers in the
northern Rockies have put together an informative fire
website
http://www.montanafires.com with news articles, photos,
satellite
imagery, and drought index maps.
3rd Annual Trek for Trees - the Red
Tree Vole Thunder Ride: August 4 and
5, join bikers in a
pledge ride for ancient forest defense. The ride
will begin in Eugene and travel to the world's oldest
treevillage at the
Clark timber sale. The
Forest Service is finalizing survey results and
giving
the okay to logging in the near future, although the area is home
to the red tree vole and the threatened spotted
owl. Food, gear van and
bike tech support
will be provided. Fundraising will help maintain the
work of Cascadia Forest Defenders. For more
information contact George
Sexton, American Lands, mailto:wafc@teleport.com.
Steve Holmer
Campaign
Coordinator
American Lands
726
7th Street SE
Washington, D.C. 20003
202/547-9105
202/547-9213 fax
mailto:wafcdc@americanlands.org
http://www.americanlands.org
Help End Child Slave Labor
Nearly half of all cocoa beans -- chocolate’s essential
ingredient -- comes from the Ivory Coast. On 600,000 small farms, young
boys pick cocoa beans from dusk to dawn. Recently, a number of factors,
including razor-thin profit margins, have
combined to tempt unscrupulous cocoa bean growers into renewing an age-old
cost-cutting method: child slave labor. The use of forced child labor isn’t
limited to the cocoa industry; the cotton and bidi-tobacco industries also
use child slaves to harvest and process their crops.
The House
recently approved a bill that could help end this tragedy by funding the
Food and Drug Administration to establish a labeling system to certify that
cocoa beans, chocolates and other derivative products are not tainted with
child slave labor. Alarmingly, Bob Dole and other Washington
lobbyists for the cocoa, cotton and bidi-tobacco industries seem intent on
blocking any Senate legislation. Don’t let this happen.
Urge the cocoa
bean and chocolate industry to immediately commit to work with child labor
experts among trade unions, nonprofits, and governments to adopt a
comprehensive action plan to end child
slavery. Click here to take action now!
To: All Activists
From: Steve
Holmer
Date: August 1, 2001
VOTE ALERT: Energy Plan Threatens Arctic
Refuge - National Forests
A
vote is expected later this afternoon whether to open Alaska's Arctic
National Wildlife Refuge to oil and gas
drilling. This is going to be a
close vote
so a final round of calls is urgently needed.
The House Republican leadership refused to allow the
Rahall/Petri
amendment which would have removed harmful
provisions to open up
National Forests and BLM lands to
increased oil and gas drilling. As a
result,
this language is expected to remain in the energy bill. This
makes a NO vote on final passage and defeating the energy
bill essential
to stop these destructive provisions.
Please contact your
Representative at 202/224-3121 right away and urge
them
to:
SUPPORT the Markey-Johnson
amendment to H.R. 4 to protect the Arctic
National
Wildlife Refuge from drilling.
Vote against final passage of the bill H.R. 4
This legislation would enact
portions of the Bush energy plan, and would
harm the
environment, threaten public health and fail to help consumers.
Instead of significantly increasing automobile and
appliance efficiency
and setting standards for
renewable energy generation, H.R. 4 will open
sensitive
areas like the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge and other
public lands to oil and gas drilling, and use at least $40
billion of
our tax dollars to subsidize polluting
energy sources including oil,
coal and nuclear fuel.
Title II of the bill allows
oil and gas drilling on Forest Service and
BLM lands
with no environmental protections stronger than those provided
by applicable state laws which in many Western states
amounts to a
virtual waiver of environmental laws such
as the Endangered Species Act.
The Forest
Service currently has the authority to limit oil, gas and
geothermal leasing on the National
Forests. However, the bill
undermines that
authority by elevating these decisions to the
Undersecretary of Agriculture which would be Mark Rey if
his nomination
is approved by the Senate.
Title II also offers a
multi-billion dollar royalty "holiday" to oil
companies
that drill in the Outer Continental Shelf in addition to
millions of dollars in new subsidies to companies drilling
on public
lands in the West. The bill would
also circumvent the recently-won
regulations forcing
Big Oil to pay fair value for oil it takes from
federal
and Indian lands. The Maloney/Napolitano amendment would delete
this provision to make sure the oil industry can't continue
shortchanging the public on drilling fees.
Steve
Holmer
Campaign Coordinator
American Lands
726 7th Street SE
Washington, D.C. 20003
202/547-9105
202/547-9213 fax
mailto:wafcdc@americanlands.org
http://www.americanlands.org
To: All Activists
From: Steve
Holmer
Date: August 1, 2001
Bush Plan Puts Roadless Areas at
Risk - Comments Needed by September 10
Despite all the greenwashing, it has become clear that the
Bush
Administration intends to rollback the roadless
area protection rule.
The Administration has failed to
defend the policy in court, and has
decided to throw
out 1.6 million comments and start the entire process
over. The Forest Service will be accepting
scoping comments until
September 10 on a new roadless
plan that listens to "local" people (i.e.
the timber
industry).
The most recent
news is that Chief Dale Bosworth is rapidly
back-tracking from his promise to personally review new
roadless area
projects. A new directive
issued yesterday by the Chief gives Regional
Foresters
discretion to allow for new projects in roadless areas. In
addition, all National Forests with completed Forest Plan
revisions
(such as the entire Pacific Northwest) are
exempted from this additional
review. This
opens the door to a new wave of roadless area logging
projects.
To stop this attack on National Forest roadless areas there
are a series
of actions that can make a huge difference
at this critical time:
1. Submit your comment by Sept. 10 to the Forest
Service and try to
generate as many additional comments
from friends, family and supporters
as
possible. See
http://www.americanlands.org/forestweb/new_roadless_comments.htm
for a
comprehensive comment letter prepared by Brian
Vincent, American Lands'
California
organizer. Talking points to address the ten scoping
questions can be found at
http://www.americanlands.org/forestweb/10_talking_points.htm
Comments should try to answer to
the ten scoping questions and must be
sent to: USDA
Forest Service-CAT, Attention: Roadless ANPR, P.O. Box
221090, Salt Lake City, Utah 84122
2. Include as much place specific
information as possible in your
comments. Chief Bosworth said that these kinds of
comments will receive
additional weight by the
agency. Please consider including a list of
every single roadless area on your nearby National Forest
along with a
brief description about the important
values found in each one.
3. Send copies of your comments to your Senators
and to your
Representative. It is essential
we keep Congress fully involved in this
process. Also please send a copy to American
Lands to help in our
public education efforts on the
Hill and with the media.
4. Please ask your Senators and Representatives
who support forest
protection to submit an official
comment in support of protecting all
roadless
areas. Thanks for all your efforts.
Steve Holmer
Campaign Coordinator
American Lands
726 7th Street SE
Washington, D.C. 20003
202/547-9105
202/547-9213 fax
mailto:wafcdc@americanlands.org
http://www.americanlands.org
In Puerto Rico, virtually all coastal areas are reported
as threatened by development. Rincon is no exception.
Help us create a Nature Reserve to protect this unique
area.
You
can take action on this alert either via email
(please
see directions below) or via the web at:
http://actionnetwork.org/campaign/trespalmas/wk8bxn2978xtdt
Help spread the word about efforts
to protect Puerto
Rico's fragile coastline. Visit the
web address below
and tell your friends to take action
on this important
campaign!
http://actionnetwork.org/campaign/trespalmas/forward/wk8bxn2978xtdt
We encourage you to take action by
October 29, 2001
Protect Unique
Caribbean Coastline
----------------------
Save Tres Palmas in Rincon, Puerto Rico
***************************
Action Network from Environmental Defense.
Finding the ways that work.
***************************
A recent report by the World
Resources Institute indicates
that nearly 60 percent of
the earth's coastal areas
are threatened by human
activity. In Puerto Rico, virtually
all coastal areas
are reported as threatened by development
and the marine
pollution it causes. In Rincon, Puerto
Rico pristine
undeveloped coastlines such as the Tres
Palmas/Domes
area are a primary attraction for thousands
of tourists
who visit the area every year to surf,
snorkel, and
enjoy the ocean.
However, the
undeveloped land, unpolluted beaches,
clear waters and
thriving reefs of this area are endangered
by proposed
development projects that involve the urbanization
and/or the construction of high rise cement buildings.
In early 2001, a coalition of
several local and national
environmental groups
(Rincon's Ecological League, Surfers
Environmental
Alliance, Surfrider Foundation, Northwest
Ecology
League, the Caribbean Action Network and Environmental
Defense) was created to protect these unique resources.
The Coalition is proposing the creation of a Nature
Reserve (the equivalent of a Coastal Commonwealth Park)
which would preserve the 262 acres of land that stretches
from the Tres Palmas/Steps beach in Bo. Ensenada, Rincon
to the lands owned by the Puerto Rico Electric Power
Authority in Bo. Puntas, Rincon.
See map of proposed reserve: http://www.surfrider.org/rincon/
A Coastal Reserve would prevent the kind of
development
that would destroy the coastal and marine
resources
that make this area an attraction for local
residents
and tourists alike. Please respond to this
action alert
as soon as possible and help us save this
pristine
area from destructive resort developments.
Sincerely,
Ken Lindeman and Azur Moulaert
Oceans Program, Environmental Defense
----------------------
INSTRUCTIONS TO RESPOND VIA THE WEB:
If you have access to a web browser, you can take action
on this alert by going to the following URL:
http://actionnetwork.org/campaign/trespalmas/wk8bxn2978xtdt
INSTRUCTIONS TO RESPOND VIA EMAIL:
Just choose the "reply to sender" option on your email
program, and edit the letter below as you wish. Do
not delete "-YOU MAY EDIT THE LETTER BELOW-" and "-END
OF LETTER-". Please do not add your name and address
to your letter. Our system automatically does this
for you.
We STRONGLY encourage you to make edits directly to
our sample letter below, and put the alert talking
points into your own words. An individualized letter
is worth ten computer generated letters. Of course,
hundreds of unedited letters will still create a large
impact, so please reply even if you don't have time
to personalize the letter.
Your letter will be addressed and sent to:
Rincon's Quality of Life Coalition
-------YOU
MAY EDIT THE LETTER BELOW---------
I support your request that the Tres Palmas through
Domes coastal area in Rincon, Puerto Rico be protected
from massive pending development by establishing a
Nature Reserve (equivalent to a Commonwealth Coastal
Park). This region of northwest Puerto Rico harbors
precious natural and community resources.
This coastline has some of the
finest elkhorn coral
reefs in the region (candidate for
the endangered species
list), sea turtle nesting sites,
humpback whale mating
grounds, pristine beaches and
valleys, and some of
the best surfing in the Atlantic
Ocean. This area is
treasured by thousands of locals
with deep ties to
the coastal land and water, and
surfing and non-surfing
tourists who help fuel the local
economy. This coastline
has a far greater value for
Puerto Rico as a protected
area.
I support the protection of this
treasure of the northern
Caribbean and support the
various local and Commonwealth
efforts to create a
Nature Reserve in Rincon.
-------END OF
LETTER-------------------------
Natural Resources Defense Council's
LEGISLATIVE WATCH
August 2, 2001
Contents:
1) Legislative Watch
2) About Our Bulletins/How to Subscribe & Unsubscribe
3) About NRDC/How to Contact Us
The information in this bulletin is
also available on our website at
http://www.nrdc.org/legislation/legwatch.asp. The web version links to
the text of bills and congressional web pages. To take
action on these
and other environmental issues, visit
NRDC's Earth Action Center at
http://www.nrdc.org/action, where you can use our online activism
tools or subscribe to Earth Action, our biweekly activist
bulletin.
1) LEGISLATIVE WATCH
This is a status report on
congressional action on the environment. To
make new or
updated sections easy to find, we've highlighted them
with:
= N O T E ! =
8/2/01
Congress is trying to wrap up several significant bills
before
recessing for the month of August. The House
approved the EPA funding
bill and harmful energy
legislation that would open up the Arctic
National
Wildlife Refuge to oil exploration, while the Senate is
considering the EPA and agriculture spending bills and will
begin
committee consideration of a comprehensive energy
bill.
...
Budget/Appropriations
= N O T E ! =
On 7/31, the Senate passed the $7.4 billion emergency
agriculture
spending bill (S. 1246). The bill contains
an additional $542 million
for wetlands, wildlife, and
farmland protection.
= N O T E !
=
On 7/30, the House approved a $7.5 billion EPA funding
bill (H.R.
2620) after amending it to prevent the Bush
administration from
delaying or weakening the new
tougher arsenic standard that was issued
in January.
Language that would have hindered efforts to address
global warming was removed from the bill, but an amendment
to restore
$25 million for the EPA's federal enforcement
activities failed by a
vote of 188-214. The bill also
undermines efforts to provide
protections against radon,
pesticides, and hazardous wastes. The
Senate's EPA bill,
which provides $7.8 billion for the agency,
including
full funding for federal enforcement efforts and greater
investments in water quality than the House bill, will
likely be
considered on the Senate floor before the
August recess. Sen. Boxer
(D-CA) is expected to offer an
amendment to maintain the stricter
arsenic standard.
= N O T E ! =
On 7/24, the House approved its Foreign Operations funding
bill, H.R.
2506. The bill includes a $25 million cut in
funding for the Global
Environment Facility, which
provides grants for projects that combat
global warming
and promote sustainable development worldwide. Funding
for the GEF in the Senate bill reported out of committee has
been
increased only slightly above last year's levels.
= N O T E ! =
On 7/19, the Senate passed the Energy and Water spending
bill, which
includes Sen. Stabenow's (D-MI) proposal to
ban oil and gas drilling
in the Great Lakes for two
years. In committee, the Senate improved a
provision
inserted in the House bill by Rep. Latham (R-IA) that would
have blocked efforts to save three endangered species on the
Missouri
River by preventing the federal government from
releasing water in the
spring to restore more natural
conditions (the Senate compromise would
allow water to
be released in the spring). The House passed its
version
of the energy and water bill on 6/28 by a vote of 405-15.
Among its troubling provisions, the bill authorizes $1
million in
studies on an expensive California water
project that would destroy
environmental resources while
failing to provide funds for
environmental restoration.
= N O T E ! =
On 7/18, the House approved funding (H.R. 2500) for the
National
Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. House
supporters of NOAA's
mission to protect the ocean
environment were able to improve language
in a rider
that undermined efforts to protect ocean wildlife and
habitats, but they were not able to remove the amendment
completely.
Rep. Olver (D-MA) was successful in removing
language from the bill
that hindered government efforts
to address global warming. The Senate
is expected to
take up its version of the bill after the August
recess.
The Senate version cuts needed marine sanctuary funding, but
does not contain the language in the House bill restricting
protection
of sensitive marine areas.
On 7/12, the Senate approved $18.5
billion to fund the Interior
department and related
agencies. The bill, H.R. 2217, includes a ban
on oil and
gas development in national monuments and bans funds for
even studying oil and gas development in sensitive coastal
waters. The
Senate also rejected an effort by the House
to prevent expanded
offshore oil and gas drilling in the
eastern Gulf of Mexico and
provided less funding for
energy efficiency than the House bill; but
rejected a
move to override environmental protections for endangered
species by depriving them of water from the Upper Klamath
Lake. On
6/21, the House passed its version of the
Interior bill by a vote of
376-32. In a great victory
for the environment, the House repeatedly
rejected key
anti-environment components of the Bush energy agenda.
Bipartisan amendments were approved to reverse Bush
administration
policies that would have allowed oil and
gas drilling within the
boundaries of national
monuments, oil and gas development off the west
coast of
Florida, and mining on public lands.
The Senate Appropriations Committee approved $60 billion for
transportation funding on 7/12 (S. 1178). On 6/26, the
House approved
its transportation funding bill (H.R.
2299). For the first time in six
years, this bill does
not include language blocking the federal
government
from considering whether vehicle fuel economy standards
should be increased.
On 7/11, the House approved the fiscal year 2002 funding
bill for the
Agriculture department by a vote of 414-16.
The House removed a ban on
using federal funds to
implement the Kyoto Protocol from the bill.
This ban had
been used to obstruct government efforts to address
global warming. However, the bill does not contain funding
for
important wetlands reserves, wildlife habitat, and
farmland
conservation programs. Environmentalists would
like to fully fund
these programs by adding $650
million.
On 7/10, the Senate
approved nearly $7 billion in supplemental funding
for
fiscal year 2001. This bill, S. 1077, contains $300 million in
financial assistance for low-income households struggling
with high
power bills this summer. The House approved
its version of the bill
(H.R. 2216) on 6/20.
On 5/6, Congress passed the Bush
administration's tax cut bill, H.R.
1836. The bill
authorizes a $1.35 trillion tax cut over the next
decade. Opponents of the cut maintain that the huge loss of
government
revenue will make it impossible to adequately
fund many important
environmental programs.
For a step-by-step guide to our
annual odyssey through resolutions,
reconciliations and
appropriations, see NRDC's budget process fact
sheet.
...
Campaign Finance Reform
On 7/12, the House rejected the campaign finance reform bill
(H.R.
2356) introduced by Rep. Shays (R-CT) and Rep.
Meehan (D-MA). The
Senate passed S. 27, Sen. McCain's
(R-AZ) and Sen. Feingold's (D-WI)
campaign finance
reform bill, on 4/2. Both bills would have banned
"soft
money" donations from corporations to political parties, which
currently are not subject to federal limits. Huge soft money
contributions from wealthy corporations have made it
easier for these
corporations to persuade members of
Congress to attach
anti-environment riders to funding
bills, and to gain special
exemptions from environmental
laws and regulations.
...
Clean Air and Energy
= N O T E ! =
The House voted on its version of an energy bill (H.R. 4) in
the early
morning hours of 8/2. The House passed four
separate energy bills out
of four different committees,
and combined them into one bill of more
than 500 pages
that does little to create a sound, balanced energy
policy. Rather, this bill would provide tens of billions of
dollars in
subsidies to coal, oil, gas and nuclear
industries, open the Arctic
National Wildlife Refuge and
other sensitive areas to oil and gas
drilling, weaken
environmental protections for other public lands, do
little to improve fuel economy standards, and starve
renewable energy
and energy efficiency programs of
needed funding.
= N O T E ! =
On 7/26, Sen. Jeffords (I-VT) held a hearing on
dangerous power plant
emissions. EPA administrator
Whitman indicated the administration's
support for
regulating mercury, sulfur dioxide, and nitrogen oxides
from power plants, but she disagreed with Sen. Jeffords'
proposal to
regulate carbon dioxide at the same time.
She also raised alarms by
suggesting that some modest
controls on three pollutants could come in
exchange for
Clean Air Act exemptions. Environmental groups support
controlling all four of the most damaging air pollutants
from power
plants.
= N O T E ! =
Throughout July Sen.
Bingaman (D-NM), the new chair of the Senate
Energy and
Natural Resources Committee, held several hearings on
energy policy bills dealing with vehicle fuel efficiency
standards,
energy efficiency, renewable energy in
general, and hydroelectric
power in particular. Sen.
Bingaman and the Senate Democratic
leadership have been
more supportive of energy conservation measures
than
their Republican counterparts, and unlike the Republican
leadership, the Democrats oppose drilling for oil and gas in
the
Arctic National Wildlife Refuge.
Sen. Reid (D-NV), the
highest-ranking Democratic member of the Senate
Environment and Public Works Committee in the
Republican-controlled
Senate, gave up his chance to
become chair of the committee when the
Democrats gained
control so that Sen. Jeffords (I-VT) could have the
position. In his new role, Sen. Jeffords will have the
opportunity to
move the bipartisan bill that he and Sen.
Lieberman (D-CT) authored to
impose mandatory cuts on
carbon pollution through committee. The
Jeffords-Lieberman bill, S. 556, has 16 cosponsors and new
momentum.
The House bill, H.R. 1256, introduced by Rep.
Boehlert (R-NY) and Rep.
Waxman (D-CA) on 3/27 has 112
cosponsors.
On 5/16, Rep. Camp
(R-MI) introduced H.R. 1864, a bipartisan bill
aimed at
making fuel-efficient hybrid gasoline-electric vehicles more
affordable, and saving consumers money at the gas pump. On
4/24, a
bipartisan group of ten senators led by Sen.
Hatch (R-UT) and Sen.
Rockefeller (D-WV) introduced S.
760, a companion Senate bill with the
same goals. The
bills link the amount of tax savings for each vehicle
to
increased fuel efficiency, and would help decrease both carbon
dioxide emissions that contribute to global warming and the
use of
petroleum fuels.
On 5/10, Rep. Olver (D-MA) and Rep. Gilchrest (R-MD)
introduced H.R.
1815, a House companion bill to S. 804.
Introduced by Senators
Feinstein (D-CA), Snowe (R-ME),
Schumer (D-NY), and Collins (R-ME) on
5/1, S. 804 seeks
to tighten corporate fuel economy standards for
sport
utility vehicles and light trucks. The bill would require that
SUVs and other light trucks increase fuel economy to 27.5
mpg by model
year 2007, expand the current fuel economy
standards to trucks
weighing between 8,500-10,000 pounds
by 2007, and raise the fuel
economy of the federal
government's fleet by 6 mpg. SUVs and light
trucks
currently use 43 percent more gasoline per mile than the
average car.
NRDC's report, A Responsible Energy Policy for the 21st
Century,
outlines the components of an alternative
energy policy -- one that
can meet the nation's energy
needs without destroying wilderness or
rolling back
environmental safeguards.
...
Clean Water
= N O T E ! =
In mid-July committees in both the House and the Senate
considered
legislation to reauthorize a popular federal
and state partnership
that provides water for urban and
agricultural users, as well as for
wildlife and habitat
restoration. Sen. Feinstein (D-CA) and Rep.
Calvert
(R-CA), both of whom have introduced bills to support the
reauthorization (S. 976 and H.R. 1985), heard testimony
emphasizing
that the bill should not support the
construction of new dams without
appropriate review, and
should not give agricultural water users
priority over
the environment. Rep. Miller (D-CA) has introduced a
bill, H.R. 2404, which would reauthorize this program
without harmful
anti-environment provisions.
Environmentalists support the Miller
bill.
...
Global Warming
= N O T E ! =
On 8/1, the Senate
Foreign Relations Committee considered the State
Department authorization bill. An amendment offered by Sen.
Kerry
(D-MA) that urges the administration to continue
to engage in
international negotiations to reduce global
warming pollution passed
unanimously. The Senate bill is
similar to the House-approved bill to
reauthorize the
State Department that contains language, added by Rep.
Menendez (D-NJ), which urges the United States to reduce
greenhouse
gases and continue to participate in
international negotiations on the
Kyoto Protocol.
= N O T E ! =
On 7/18, Sen. Lieberman (D-CT), chair of the Senate
Governmental
Affairs Committee, held a hearing on a bill
(S. 1008) introduced by
Sen. Byrd (D-WV) and Sen.
Stevens (R-AK) that creates a framework for
the United
States to develop a comprehensive program to reduce
pollution that contributes to global warming. The bill is
expected to
be considered on 8/2.
...
International Environmental Protections
On June 13, Rep. Crane (R-IL)
introduced H.R. 2149, the Trade
Promotion Authority Act
of 2001. This bill grants the president "fast
track," or
expedited, authority to negotiate new trade agreements.
However, the bill prevents labor and environmental standards
from
being addressed, and allows trade rules to directly
challenge
legitimate public interest laws and
regulations. The bill, supported
by the Bush
administration, is similar to fast track legislation that
was rejected by Congress in 1997 and 1998, except that it
provides
even fewer positive labor and environmental
provisions, while offering
more restrictions on public
safety and environmental protection. A
broad coalition
of public interest organizations has voiced its
opposition to any fast track legislation that does not
adequately
address environmental, labor, and social
justice issues. The House is
expected to take the bill
up after the August recess.
...
Public Health
= N O T E ! =
On 7/27, 19 Republicans joined 198 Democrats and one
Independent to
support an amendment to the EPA funding
bill (H.R. 2620) that would
ensure the implementation of
the stricter arsenic drinking water
standard approved
during the last weeks of the Clinton administration.
The
tougher standard decreases permissible levels of arsenic in
drinking water from 50 parts per billion to 10 ppb. EPA
administrator
Whitman suspended the new rule on 5/22.
On 5/22, the House unanimously
approved H.R. 1831, a bipartisan bill
that exempts
municipal solid waste and small quantities of hazardous
waste from Superfund liability. This bipartisan compromise
legislation
moved swiftly through the House because it
had the support of key
leaders on both the Commerce
Committee and the Transportation
Committee.
On 5/3, Sen. Chafee (R-RI)
introduced a bill (S. 830) that would fund
research into
links between breast cancer and the environment. Rep.
Lowey (D-NY) introduced a House companion bill (H.R. 1723)
on the same
day.
On 4/26, Sen. Boxer (D-CA) led six other Democratic senators
in
offering S. 796, a bill designed to inform the public
about the health
dangers associated with arsenic in
drinking water. The bill also seeks
to inform people
that the EPA has decided not to strengthen the
arsenic
standards because of cost concerns.
On 4/25, by a vote of 99-0, the Senate approved a popular
bipartisan
brownfields redevelopment bill (S. 350),
introduced by Senators Smith
(R-NH), Chafee (R-RI), Reid
(D-NV), and Boxer (D-CA). The bill
provides states with
increased funding and authority to clean up
former
industrial sites known as brownfields. The bill now moves to
the House, where its fate is uncertain. The Bush
administration has
signaled its support for the bill,
but with funding extremely tight,
finding money in the
budget for brownfields clean-up may be difficult.
On 4/4, Rep. Waxman (D-CA) introduced H.R. 1413, which would
reinstate
the arsenic-in-drinking-water standard of 10
parts per billion (ppb)
issued by the Clinton
administration in January and revoked by the
Bush
administration in late March. This bill would also provide
funding for local water authorities to bring their systems
into
compliance. With 173 cosponsors and the support of
environmental and
public health groups, the bill's
supporters are pushing hard to
quickly bring it to the
floor of the House. In a move also applauded
by
environmentalists, Rep. Sanders (I-VT) has introduced H.R. 1252, a
bill that would establish an arsenic-in-drinking-water
standard even
lower than the 10 ppb standard in H.R.
1413.
...
Public Lands
= N O T E ! =
On 7/25, the House Resources Committee approved the
controversial
Conservation and Reinvestment Act (H.R.
701). CARA would provide
funding for state and federal
conservation and wildlife initiatives,
however,
environmentalists do not support the bill in its present form
because it could create significant incentives for oil and
gas
drilling off Alaska's coast. It also fails to ensure
that the funds it
makes available would be used for
environmental projects rather than
for roads and
infrastructure. Moreover, a funding deal negotiated last
year by the Clinton administration and Rep. Dicks (D-WA)
achieves many
of CARA's positive goals without the
anti-environment provisions.
On
7/12, the Senate approved, by voice vote, the nomination of J.
Steven Griles to be second in command at the Department of
the
Interior. Griles served in President Reagan's
Interior department for
eight years. He is a lobbyist
and a former industry official who is
expected to push
for more industry resource extraction from, and less
environmental protection for, public lands.
On 7/10, the House approved H.R.
2131, a noncontroversial bill
introduced by Rep. Portman
(R-OH) that reauthorizes a "debt for
nature" swap
program that allows other countries to apply debt
payments to projects aimed at saving tropical forests. The
Senate
could take up Sen. Lugar's (R-IN) version of this
legislation, S.
1021, before the August recess.
On 6/7, Rep. Simpson (R-ID)
introduced the National Monument Fairness
Act of 2001
(H.R. 2114), a bill seeking to curb the president's
ability to either designate new national monuments or expand
existing
national monuments under the 1906 Antiquities
Act. This bill, which
would require congressional
approval for monuments over 50,000 acres
in size, is
opposed by the environmental community because it would
hinder swift presidential action to protect important public
resources
that are threatened by development.
On 5/1, the House unanimously passed
a substantially improved version
of H.R. 601, a bill
that redesignates a portion of the Craters of the
Moon
National Monument in Idaho as a preserve where traditional
hunting would be allowed. Environmentalists did not oppose
the final
version of this bill, because it reflects an
agreement that the
Clinton administration had reached
with the local community, and it
ensures that the
Interior Department retain oversight of hunting
there.
...
Regulatory Reform
= N O T E ! =
On 7/19, the Senate
confirmed John Graham by a vote of 61-37 for a key
position within the White House that makes recommendations
on
regulations. Sen. Durbin (D-IL), Sen. Lieberman
(D-CT), Sen. Wellstone
(D-MN) and Sen. Kerry (D-MA)
raised strong objections to his
nomination during floor
debate. Environmental, labor, and consumer
groups
opposed Graham's nomination because he consistently advocates
an ideological approach to regulation that is hostile to
strong
environmental, health, and safety protections.
...
For information on the environmental voting records of
members of
Congress, see the League of Conservation
Voter's National
Environmental Scorecards at http://www.lcv.org/scorecards/index.htm
...........
2) About Our Bulletins/How to Subscribe & Unsubscribe
NRDC distributes three bulletins
by email. To subscribe to any or all
of them or to join
our activist networks, go to
http://www.join.nrdcaction.org/subscribe.asp. If you already subscribe
and want to change your subscriptions or update your email
address or
other information, go to http://www.join.nrdcaction.org/profileeditor
(or see the
unsubscribe information below).
EARTH ACTION is sent biweekly and calls out urgent
environmental
issues requiring immediate action. To
unsubscribe from Earth Action,
send an email message to
earthaction@nrdcaction.org with REMOVE in the
subject
line.
LEGISLATIVE WATCH is sent
biweekly when Congress is in session and
tracks
environmental bills moving through the federal legislature. To
unsubscribe from Legislative Watch, send an email message to
legwatch@nrdcaction.org with REMOVE in the subject line.
The CALIFORNIA ACTIVIST NETWORK
ACTION ALERT is distributed monthly to
members of NRDC's
California Activist Network and provides action
tools to
Californians and others concerned with protecting the state's
natural resources and the health of its citizens. To
unsubscribe, send
an email message to
wildcalifornia@nrdcaction.org with REMOVE in the
subject
line.
...........
3) About NRDC/How to Contact Us
The Natural Resources Defense
Council is a nonprofit environmental
organization with
over 500,000 members nationwide and a staff of
scientists, attorneys and environmental experts. Our mission
is to
protect the planet's wildlife and wild places and
ensure a safe and
healthy environment for all living
things.
For more information
about NRDC or how to become a member of NRDC,
please
contact us at:
Natural Resources
Defense Council
40 West 20th Street
NY, NY 10011
212-727-4511 (voice) /
212-727-1773 (fax)
General information:
nrdcinfo@nrdc.org
Email subscription questions:
nrdcaction@nrdc.org
http://www.nrdc.org
Also visit:
BioGems -- Saving
Endangered Wild Places
A project of the Natural
Resources Defense Council
http://www.savebiogems.org
Welcome to the EarthNet News -- the largest student
environmental newsletter in
the U.S.! Each week, we'll
bring you legislative updates, corporate attacks on
the
environment, and political, environmental, and campus news. Check out our
website at http://www.envirocitizen.org to take action on our
alerts, find jobs
or events in your area, and learn
about our campaigns on campus or in your
community. If
you received this by mistake, please refer to instructions at the
bottom of the newsletter. You may receive
two editions of EarthNet News this
time. Our
listserv manager will address the problem this month and it
shouldn't happen again.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EarthNet News
...a project of
the Center for Environmental Citizenship
August 2, 2001
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Come join the fray as summer heats
up! Protest HR 4, which will allow for
drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, and stop
big corporations from
muzzling nonprofits and trammeling
first amendment rights! And check out our
job
listings … you know us, you love us, and now you can come work with us here
at the Center for Environmental Citizenship (we currently
have two fab
openings). We also have a
suggestion for what to do with your phat tax refund
that
just might help to undo some of the damage Mama Earth's sustained lately.
And if that isn't enough for you, we STILL offer free
Web-based
EnviroCitizen.com email at http://www.envirocitizen.org/mail
--Susie Gorden, EarthNet Editor
mailto:earthnet@envirocitizen.org
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Shadow Congress: Stop HR 4!
2. Corporate Corner: Support Nonprofits &
the First Amendment!
3. Quote of the Week
4. Glimmer(s) of Hope
5. Letter to
the Editor
** An Interruption **
6. Eco-Exposure
7. Jobs, Conferences
and Gatherings
8. Activist Phone Book & EarthNet
News Info
SHADOW CONGRESS
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
If you've been following the summer's heated debates
over energy, then you'll
know HR 4 is here and it ain't
good! The House approved this bill August 1,
which contains billions in tax breaks for the power industry
and allows for
drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife
Reserve (ANWR). As Rep. Richard
Gephardt
(D-MO) said during House debate, "The bill, much like the president's
energy program, takes us back to a different, much earlier
era: to a 1950s'
world of big oil rigs and refineries."
But it's not too
late! Congress adjourns at the end of the week -- and then HR
4 heads to the Senate, who will begin debating the bill
after Labor Day. Its
fate is still far from
certain.
TAKE ACTION
NOW: Write your Senator now to stop HR 4 and protect the ANWR,
sending letters from http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet
FOR MORE INFO:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A16582-2001Aug1.html;
http://www.alaskawild.org/arcticrefuge_intro.html
CORPORATE
CORNER
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Have you ever noticed that the organizations that are
the most likely to work
against liberty frequently throw
around the word freedom? Well, the Frontiers
of Freedom (FF) is no different. They're
currently in a fight to revoke the
tax-exempt status of
the Rainforest Action Network (RAN) -- an act that would
certainly bankrupt the organization.
Educating the public about
for-profit misdeeds is a cornerstone for many
nonprofits
-- including what you read here in "Corporate Corner." But FF is
targeting RAN for the campaign they've waged against Boise
Cascade Corporation,
one of the worst offenders in
trafficking products from old-growth forests.
The issue
is attracting big-time celebrity attention -- Bonnie Raitt and Julia
Butterfly Hill were arrested in Chicago last week and
letters of support have
come in from Michael Stipe and
Oliver Stone. Join with them in protesting this
blatant first amendment attack!
TAKE ACTION NOW: Write Charles Rossotti, Internal
Revenue Service
Commissioner, to protect RAN's nonprofit
status and first amendment rights!
Use the EarthNet
Action Center at http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet to make
your
views heard.
FOR MORE INFO:
http://www.ran.org/ran_campaigns/old_growth/ran_boise_response.html;
http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20010726/re/people_raitt_dc_1.html;
QUOTE OF THE WEEK
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Only after the last tree has been cut down. Only after
the last river has been
poisoned. Only after the last
fish has been caught. Only then you will find
that money
cannot be eaten.
-- Cree Indian Proverb
GLIMMER(S) OF HOPE: Part Uno
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Never underestimate the power of youth. This
spring, a community group in
Jamaica Plain, MA, a
neighborhood of Boston, successfully lowered the voting
age for local elections to 16, arguing that youth are
frequently the voice of
the parents in this largely
immigrant neighborhood. But the Hyde Square Task
Force didn't stop there. They subsequently ran
two 16-year-olds for the
community council -- electing
both Kimberly Chacon and Oscar Vega. Even more
incredibly, the two were the largest vote-getters in their
areas for the spring
election. Both are
currently fighting to designate an empty lot as a community
center that would benefit local youth, instead of handing it
over to big
developers who want to open a
K-Mart. Sounds like a fight worth winning!
GLIMMER(S) OF HOPE: Part Deux
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
So the news on the home front hasn't been great
regarding the Kyoto Treaty …
The Bush administration's
rejection of the climate change treaty didn't stop a
whopping 178 nations from signing on recently in Bonn,
Germany. While the U.S.
is still the single
largest polluter, this amazing show of solidarity
represents a major step in recognizing the need to limit
carbon emissions and
mitigate the effects of climate
change. Two cheers for the rest of the world!
AN INTERRUPTION
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
I now interrupt your regularly scheduled EarthNet News
programming with an
important
announcement. You might be wondering what to do with that phat tax
refund you'll be receiving any day. Well, it
would be great if you'd consider
sponsoring our work at
the Center for Environmental Citizenship. And there's
no better time to do it! Right now, we're one of
the featured charities
sponsored by Give for Change, a
program of Working Assets. Donate online
(http://www.giveforchange.com) and Working Assets will
match your $300 or $600
donation $ for
$. (We'll happily accept any amount, but they'll only provide
matching funds for $300 or $600.) If the money's already
spoken for in your own
abode, think about other folks
who might have enough spare cash to help us do
the
important work of igniting youth power to protect the environment.
ECO-EXPOSURE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
MTV challenges young activists to fight for your rights
and qualify for a
scholarship worth up to
$50,000. See if you're eligible and check out the
details at http://www.mtv.com/nav/intro_ffyr.html
LETTERS TO
THE EDITOR
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
And speaking of Kyoto…
To the Editor:
I would like to see Ford adopt the Kyoto Treaty. But our own
President, and
therefore the nation, does
not. Yes, there are countries that are being
hypocritical about the Treaty. They expect the
U.S. to adopt it because we are
such a big consumer
country. Well, fellow Americans, we are!
Just take a look around you as you drive (alone) around:
There are many SUVs
out there, blah-blah-valve, 4.0 or
more liter, six-cylinder 4-wheel drive
vehicles that
will NEVER touch a knobby, rutted, dirt or even gravel road.
One caveat: I drive a small pickup,
which does NOT get the mileage of a Geo
Metro. But not
only do I have a small, 2.5-liter manual transmission Dakota, I
don't even have air conditioning! And you know what else? I
USE it the way a
pickup is built to be used: I haul
recycled mulch from the dump to my herb
garden. I help
people move (which is the curse of truck owners). I also combine
trips...never one trip to the grocery store and when it is a
code RED day, I
never gas up and make trips as little as
possible.
Okay, I'm
sanctimonious. But when I see a Mercedes SUV, with a driver that has
one hand on the wheel and another on his/her cell phone, I
ask myself "Why
don't you get something more gas
efficient? And by the way, why don't you pull
off to the
side of the road, cut your engine, and talk?
Back to the Kyoto Treaty: Well, what do you expect from a
Chump-Off-The-Old-Blockhead? But I believe that we
should have adopted Kyoto
and set a good example for
ourselves and the world.
-- Clay
Teunis, Environmental Journalism Academy, Alumnus '99
Got something to
say? Send your letters to mailto:earthnet@envirocitizen.org
We reserve the right to edit for length, clarity, and
purpose.
JOBS AND INTERNSHIPS
------------------------------
These
are a sampling of the over 200 environmental and activist jobs and
internships listed at
www.envirocitizen.org/enet/jobs/index.asp!
The Center for Environmental Citizenship is searching for a
Training Director
(http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/jobs/detail.asp?id=3114)
AND a Development
Director
(http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/jobs/detail.asp?id=3068).
The Student Conservation
Association seeks conservation leaders for paid
internships in Hawley, MA. Find the job
description at
http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/jobs/detail.asp?id=3057
The Southern Appalachian Forest
Coalition is looking for a Field Organizer in
Asheville,
NC. Find the job description at
http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/jobs/detail.asp?id=3189
The Northwest Jewish
Environmental Project is hiring a Program Director in
Seattle, WA. Find the job description at
http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/jobs/detail.asp?id=3164
CONFERENCES, GATHERINGS AND VIEWINGS
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
All events listed at http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/events/index.asp
WHAT: "In the Light of Reverence," a
documentary about environmental
protection and Native
American religious freedom
WHERE: Nationally broadcast
on
PBS
WHEN: August 17, 2001
FOR MORE INFO: http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/events/detail.asp?id=858
WHAT: International Action
Camp
WHERE: Chicago, IL
WHEN: August 18 - August 24, 2001
FOR MORE INFO: http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/events/detail.asp?id=814
WHAT: Globalization and the
Environment: Prospects and Perils
WHERE: Anaheim, CA
WHEN: August 24 , 2001
FOR MORE INFO: http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/events/detail.asp?id=823
ACTIVIST PHONE BOOK
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
U.S. Capitol Switchboard: 202.224.3121
White House Comment Line: 202.456.1111
EarthNet Action Center: http://congress.nw.dc.us/cec
White House Address: 1600 Pennsylvania Ave, Washington, DC
20500
Senate Address: US Senate, Washington, DC 20510
House Address: US House of Representatives, Washington,
DC 20515
**Look up e-mail addresses in a comprehensive
congressional directory at
http://congress.nw.dc.us/cec/congdir.html or http://www.vote-smart.org/ce
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Write your own short articles for submission to
EarthNet. We are particularly
interested in articles
about student activism on your campus. The email
accounts for EarthNet News are:
For
general comments: mailto:earthnet@envirocitizen.org
For
article submissions or ideas: mailto:submissions@envirocitizen.org
Submit Jobs/Internships/Volunteer listings at
http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/jobs/add.asp.
Submit Events at http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/events/add.asp.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To subscribe to our listserv, EarthNet News, go to
http://www.envirocitizen.org/subscribe.html, or send an
email to
mailto:earthnet-request@earthsystems.org with
the subject subscribe
In this Post :
1. Amazon Watch, Project Underground, Rainforest Action
Network Press Release
2. U'wa communique in English and
Espanol
For background info on
the U'wa struggle check out http://www.ran.org
http://www.amazonwatch.org www.moles.org or the U'wa own
website at
http://www.uwacolombia.org
AMAZON WATCH * PROJECT
UNDERGROUND *¨RAINFOREST ACTION NETWORK
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE August 1, 2001
CONTACTS:
Atossa Soltani, Amazon Watch - (202) 256-9795
Patrick Reinsborough, Rainforest Action Network (415)
305-7246
Carwil James, Project Underground (510)
705-8981
Colombia's U'wa Tribe and Supporters Celebrate Oxy's Failure
to Find Oil
End to Oil Drilling on the Tribe's Ancestral Land and
Total De-Militarization Urged
The news long awaited by the Colombia's U'wa tribe and their
thousands
of supporters around the world has finally
arrived: the Los
Angeles-based Occidental Petroleum
(OXY) announced Friday that it has
failed to find oil at
the Gibraltar 1 well site on the tribe's ancestral
land
in Northeastern Colombia. The company has begun removing equipment
from the site, a positive turn of events for the valorous
non-violent
resistance campaign waged by the U'wa, an
indigenous community of 8,000
who live high in the
Andean cloud forests.
Since OXY
received drilling rights in 1992 to the Siriri block (formerly
known as Samoré), the project has been embroiled in
controversy and
condemned by environmental and human
rights groups worldwide.
The
announcement by OXY comes as thousands of U'wa are taking part in a
traditional three month spiritual retreat for fasting,
meditation,
teaching, singing, and prayer. The U'wa
Werjayas (spiritual leaders) and
Karekas(medicine
people) have been praying for months and using
traditional rituals to "hide the oil" from OXY's drill.
While the U'wa called this
development a "cultural triumph," the tribe
pointed out
that their ancestral land is still threatened by oil
exploration by the Spanish company Repsol, who is just
beginning
exploratory drilling in the Capachos 1
block. "This is a battle that we
have won,
but the war continues, because the U'wa territory is not only
Gibraltar 1," said Roberto Perez, President of the U'wa
Traditional
Authority in a communiqué released today.
"The blood spilled from the
three North Americans indigenous activists
and other
supporters who were killed, the loss of our U'wa children in
the violent evictions, the humiliations of the armed forces,
the cries
of the U'wa children and elders in the
peaceful mobilizations, the
challenge to resist the
aggressions by the Colombian State and OXY, will
not go
unpunished. It will be a bittersweet memory that will remain in
the minds of those who participated directly an indirectly
in the most
difficult moments
of
this process," said Perez.
The
U'wa have become a symbol of resistance to oil exploration and
corporate led globalization for thousands of supporters
around the
world. Over the last 5 years, the
U'wa resistance has inspired a
massive international
solidarity movement that has captured headlines
with
hundreds of peaceful demonstrations. More recently, the U'wa and
their supporters been organizing to stop U.S. military aid
to Colombia,
of which OXY is an influential proponent.
Using tactics ranging from
blockades at the drill site, lawsuits,
shareholder
resolutions, letter writing campaigns, banner hangs, and
non-violent civil disobedience, the U'wa along with
environmental and
human rights activists have confronted
Occidental and its major
shareholders including Fidelity
Investments, former Vice-President Al
Gore and Alliance
Capital/Sanford Bernstein.
"This is an important victory and a real milestone in the
larger
struggle to win recognition and respect for
indigenous peoples rights
around the
world. Unfortunately, until we address our societies
addiction to fossil fuels by transitioning to renewable
energy sources,
the world's remaining pristine
ecosystems and traditional cultures will
continue to be
threatened by unscrupulous oil corporations," said Kevin
Koenig, campaigner for Amazon Watch.
This is yet another blow to Oxy's
operations in Colombia which have
suffered significant
losses this year. The company's Cano Limon field
and pipeline have been paralyzed since February 17 as a
result of more
than 110 guerrilla bombings on the
company's pipeline so far this year.
In
addition, OXY's private security contractor, AirScan, was recently
implicated in one of Colombian Military's worst civilian
massacres
putting OXY in the center of yet another
controversy. AirScan guided
Colombian military's attack
on the Santo Domingo village that killed 12
civilians
including 9 children.
The U'wa
Communique (in English and Spanish) follow this release.
###
ASSOCIATION OF U'WA TRADITIONAL AUTHORITIES
DECREE No. 1088 of 1993
January 7, 1997 Resolution of Registry No. 003
General Office of Indigenous Affairs. Ministry of the
Interior
COMMUNIQUE TO NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY
GIBRALTAR 1,
CULTURAL TRIUMPH
THE U'WA WILL CONTINUE TO DEFEND OUR
MOTHER EARTH
EL KERA CHIKARA = SACRED TERRITORY
Cubará, July 31, 2001
Recently, the U.S multinational
company Occidental of Colombia (OXY)
publicly recognized
the negative results regarding the expected
petroleum
bonanza of Gibraltar 1.
For the
U'wa, after doing a meticulous study of our origin, our history
and of the flagrant violations of our great laws committed
by the
Colombian state and OXY, we knew this news months
before. For our
highest traditional
authorities WERJAYAS, defenders of the landmarks of
the
world, it's a battle that has been won, but the war continues
because the U'wa territory is not only Gibraltar
1. Our territory is
more extensive, covering
five Colombian states (Casanare, Arauca,
Boyacá,
Santander and North Santander) and part of
the
Venezuelan territory, today known as the state of Merida.
We say that it is only one battle
and more await us, for today, the
Sacred U'wa territory
remains threatened by the petroleum exploration
project
BLOQUE CAPACHOS I, in the jurisdiction of the Tame - Arauca
municipality, carried out by the SPANISH PETROLEUM
MULTINATIONAL REPSOL
EXPLORACIÓN COLOMBIA,
S.A. The indigenous reserve of Angostura, which
is home to U'wa (with 3,200 hectares), Macarieros (40
hectares) and
Payeros (the last of the Sikuani ethnic
group with 94 hectares) are all
being affected.
The National Government's
administrative procedures for the BLOQUE
CAPACHOS I,
headed by the Minister of the Environment and the Ministry
of the Interior (under the direction of the General of
Indigenous
Affairs), secretly moved ahead ignoring the
process of consultation and
agreement with the U'wa and
Sikuani communities, as we are the ones that
are
directly affected by the project. This is the same obscure and
deceptive process that moved ahead in Gibraltar I.
In the face of this event, the U'wa
will inform our highest authorities
to make decisions in
how to act materially and spiritually to resist
this
project.
The knowledge inherited
from our ancestors and the spiritual
communication with
the eternal father SIRA that we zealously preserve
and
practice today, allows us to reaffirm our vision and cultural
mission, which we are obligated to defend with
dignity. THE RESPECT FOR
THE LIFE OF MOTHER
EARTH AND ALL THAT EXISTS UPON HER.
It is also right to say that in this first defense we were
accompanied
unrestrictedly by the social sectors from
the state of Arauca, Cubará
(Boyacá) and Toledo (North
Santander), the indigenous brothers of
Colombia and all
Colombians who felt and observed powerlessly the
physical and verbal aggressions we were subjected to in
search for
respect of our sacred rights.
The blood spilled of the North
Americans indigenous women and activist
who were killed,
the loss of our U'wa children in the violent evictions,
the humiliations of the armed forces, the cries of the U'wa
children and
elders in the peaceful mobilizations, the
challenge to resist the
aggressions by the Colombian
State and OXY, will not go unpunished.
They
will be a memory with a bittersweet taste that will remain in the
minds of those who participated directly and indirectly in
the most
difficult moments of this
process. The vigilant and zealous spirit of our
martyrs strengthens us
to reaffirm the process of
defense of our Historical Patrimonial
Millennial
Rights. Moreover, we highlight the international support
that we have counted on with their moral, ethical, spiritual
and
economic solidarity to resist against the invasion
of our sacred spaces.
We invite
all our friends of Colombia and the World to continue their
solidarity with the U'wa people in our second phase of
resistance
against petroleum companies and the Colombian
State that continue to
ignore our territorial and
cultural rights. The U'wa have always
respected that which belongs to others, but the government
and
multinational corporations continue to violate our
rights.
Finally, we insist that
the Colombian Government comply with the
recuperation
and legalization of the united U'wa Reserve.
Cultures with principles cannot be bought.
U'WA TRADITIONAL AUTHORITIES
Roberto
Pérez Gutierrez
President of U'wa Traditional Authority
U'wa Association
Office of Cabildo Mayor
U'wa Telefax 0978 892326
WE ARE THE
CHILDREN OF THE EARTH, HELP US DEFEND IT
------------------------
Espanol
COMUNICADO A LA OPINIÓN PÚBLICA
Cubará, Julio 31 de 2001
GIBRALTAR: TRIUNFO CULTURAL
LOS U´WA SEGUIREMOS DEFENDIENDO A NUESTRA MADRE TIERRA
EL KERA CHIKARA : TERRITORIO SAGRADO
Recientemente la empresa multinacional estadounidense de
petróleo
Occidental de Colombia, OXY, reconoció
públicamente los resultados
desalentadores frente a la
expectativa de la bonanza petrolera de
Gibraltar I, en
territorio sagrado U´wa.
Para
los U´was luego de hacer un estudio minucioso de nuestro origen de
nuestra historia y de la flagrante violación de nuestras
leyes mayores,
de los derechos fundamentales consagrados
en la Constitución Política de
1991 y las leyes
internacionales, por parte del Estado Colombiano y de
la
Oxy, meses antes conocíamos esta noticia, lo cual nos tranquilizó y
nuestra noble actitud fue retirarnos de la protesta pacifica
para
continuar con nuestros ayunos sagrados de
purificación y meditación.
Para nuestras
máximas autoridades tradicionales Werjayas sostenedores de
los mejores del Corazón del Mundos, es una batalla que se
gana pero la
guerra del conocimiento por defender la
vida de la madre tierra y de
nuestros hermanos riowa
continua
porque el territorio U´wa no solo es Gibraltar
I, nuestro territorio es
mas extenso, tiene espacio
geográfico en cinco departamentos de Colombia
(Casanare,
Arauca, Boyará, Santander y Norte de Santander) y parte del
territorio venezolano, hoy territorio del Estado de Mérida.
Decidimos que es solo una
batalla y nos esperan muchas mas, pues hoy, el
territorio sagrado U´wa sigue amenazado con el proyecto
petrolero BLOQUE
CAPACHOS I, en jurisdicción del
municipio de Tame - Arauca, adelantado
por la
Multinacional petrolera Española REPSOL EXPLORACION COLOMBIA SA.
En el desarrollo de este proyecto se están afectando los
resguardos
indígenas de Angostura de la etnia U´wa,
Macarieros y Puyeros de la
etnia Sikuani que de por si
ya ha sido destruida en su mayor parte con
el proyecto
de explotación petrolera de Caño Limón en Arauca, que
adelanta la Oxy.
Los tramites administrativos del BLOQUE CAPACHOS por parte
del Gobierno
Nacional en cabeza del Ministro del Medio
Ambiente y el Ministerio del
Interior, a través de la
Dirección de General de Asuntos Indígenas se
adelanto
escondida, desconociéndose el proceso de consulta y
concertación con los Pueblos U'WA y Sikuani quienes somos
los directos
afectados con este proyecto. Es
el mismo proceso oscuro y engañoso que
se adelanto en
Gibraltar I.
Frente a este hecho
los U´was informaremos a nuestras máximas
autoridades
para tomar decisiones de cómo actuar material y
espiritualmente para contrarrestar este proyecto.
La sabiduría heredada de nuestros
ancestros y la comunicación espiritual
con el padre
eterno Sira que hoy celosamente conservamos y practicamos,
nos permiten reafirmar nuestra visión y misión cultural que
estamos
obligados a defender con dignidad. EL
RESPETO POR LA VIDA DE LA MADRE
TIERRA Y TODO
LO QUE EXISTE SOBRE ELLA.
También es bueno decir que en esta primera defensa nos
acompañaron
irrestrictamente los sectores sociales del
departamento de Arauca, de
Cubara (Boyacá) y Toledo
(Norte de Santander), los hermanos indígenas de
Colombia
y todos los colombianos que sintieron y observaron impotentes
las agresiones físicas y verbales a loas que fuimos
sometidos por buscar
el respeto de nuestros derechos
sagrados.
La sangre derramada de
los tres indigenistas norteamericanos, la perdida
de
nuestro niños U´wa en los desalojos violentos, las humillaciones de
la fuerza publica, el llanto de los niños, niñas y ancianos
U´wa en las
movilizaciones pacificas, el reto por
contrarrestar las agresiones del
Estado y de la Oxy no
quedaran impunes, será un recuerdo con sabor
amargo y
dulce que quedara en la mente de los que participamos directa e
indirectamente en los momentos mas difíciles de este
proceso. El
espíritu vigilante y celoso de
nuestros mártires nos fortalece para
reafirmar el
proceso de defensa de nuestros derechos históricos
patrimoniales milenarios.
Así mismo
es de resaltar el apoyo internacional con quienes hemos
contado con la solidaridad moral, ética, espiritual para
resistir frente
a la invasión de nuestros espacios
sagrados.
Invitamos a todos
nuestros amigos y amigas de Colombia y del Mundo a
continuar solidarizándose con el pueblo U´wa en nuestra
segunda etapa de
resistencia contra las petroleras y el
Estado que están desconociendo
nuestros derechos
territoriales y culturales. Los U´wa siempre hemos
respetado lo ajeno, pero el gobierno y las empresas
multinacionales
siguen violando nuestros derechos.
Finalmente queremos exigir al
Gobierno Colombiano el inmediato
saneamiento del
Resguardo Unido U´wa.
Las
culturas con principios no tienen precio
AUTORIDADES TRADICIONALES U´WA
Roberto Pérez Gutiérrez
Presidente
Cabildo Mayor
Asociación U´wa
SOMOS LOS HIJOS DE LA TIERRA,
AYÚDANOS A DEFENDERLA
ASOCIACION
DE AUTORIDADES TRADICIONALES U'WA
(Decreto 1088 de 1993
Resolución de Registro No. 003 de 1997 Dirección
General
de Asuntos Indígenas Ministerio del Interior)
Oficina
Cabildo Mayor U'wa Calle 4 No. 3-53 Centro de Desarrollo
Comunitario
Telefax 0978
892326
Cubará Boyacá
RAFI
Rural Advancement Foundation
International
www.rafi.org | rafi@rafi.org
News Release - 3 August 2001
USDA Says Yes to Terminator
It's official. The US Department of
Agriculture announced this week that
it has concluded
negotiations to license the notorious Terminator
technology to its seed industry partner, Delta & Pine
Land (D&PL). As a
result of joint research, the USDA
and D&PL are co-owners of three
patents on the
controversial technology that genetically modifies plants
to produce sterile seeds, preventing farmers from re-using
harvested
seed. A licensing agreement establishes the
terms and conditions under
which a party can use a
patented technology. Although many of the Gene
Giants
hold patents on Terminator technology, D&PL is the only company
that has publicly declared its intention to commercialize
Terminator
seeds. (for details, see "2001: A Seed
Odyssey" RAFI Communique,
January/February 2001,
www.rafi.org)
"USDA's decision
to license Terminator flies in the face of
international
public opinion and betrays the public trust," said Hope
Shand, Research Director of RAFI. "Terminator technology has
been
universally condemned by civil society; banned by
international
agricultural research institutes, censured
by United Nations bodies,
even shunned by Monsanto, and
yet the US government has officially
sanctioned
commercialization of the technology by licensing it to one of
the world's largest seed companies," explains Shand.
"USDA's role in developing
Terminator seeds is a disgraceful example of
corporate
welfare involving a technology that is bad for farmers,
dangerous for the environment and disastrous for world food
security,"
adds Silvia Ribeiro of RAFI. Terminator has
been universally opposed as
an immoral technology
because over 1.4 billion people, primarily poor
farmers,
depend on farm-saved seeds as their primary seed source.
Michael Schechtman, Executive
Secretary to USDA's Advisory Committee on
Agricultural
Biotechnology, made the official announcement regarding the
licensing of Terminator at the Committee's August 1 meeting.
The
38-member Advisory Committee, established during the
Clinton
administration, was created to advise the
Secretary of Agriculture on
issues related to growing
public controversy over GM technology. Because
of
overwhelming public opposition to USDA's involvement with Terminator,
the issue became a top priority for the Advisory Committee.
USDA
officials admitted last year that the Agency had
the option of
abandoning patents on Terminator, but
chose not to do so. Although many
members of the Biotech
Advisory Committee urged the USDA to abandon its
patents
and forsake all further research on genetic seed sterilization,
the USDA steadfastly declined. The official statement
released by USDA
this week states that the Agency "had a
legal obligation" to license the
technology to D&PL.
In a lackluster attempt to quell
its critics, the USDA pledged to
negotiate licensing
restrictions on how the Terminator technology could
be deployed by Delta & Pine Land. "In the
end, the restrictions
negotiated by USDA are
meaningless," concludes Michael Sligh, RAFI-USA's
Director of Sustainable Agriculture, and member of the
Biotech Advisory
Committee. According to Sligh, "USDA's
promotion of Terminator
technology puts private profits
above public good and the rights of
farmers everywhere."
Sligh spearheaded efforts amongst Advisory Board
members
who urged the USDA to abandon Terminator.
USDA places the following conditions on D&PL's
deployment of
Terminator:
_ The licensed Terminator technology will not be used in any
heirloom
varieties of garden flowers and vegetables and
it will not be used in
any variety of plant available in
the marketplace before January 1,
2003. (RAFI's comment:
In other words, Terminator will not be
commercialized,
at the earliest, until 2003 - only 17 months from now.
To suggest that USDA is protecting heirloom varieties from
genetic seed
sterilization technology is ludicrous.
There's no money to be made on
genetic modification of
heirloom vegetables and flowers. The seed
industry aims
to engineer seed sterility in major crop commodities -
especially those crops that have not been successfully
hybridized on a
commercial scale such as soybeans, rice
and wheat.)
_ USDA
scientists will be involved in safety testing of new varieties
incorporating the GM trait for seed sterility, and a full
and public
process of safety evaluation must be
completed prior to regulatory
sign-off by USDA.(RAFI's
comment: Can USDA play a role in both
developing and
regulating this technology? Is it a blatant conflict of
interest for the agency to conduct a biosafety review of a
product in
which it holds a financial interest?)
_ All royalties accruing to USDA
from the use of Terminator will be
earmarked to
technology transfer efforts for USDA's Agricultural
Research Service innovations that will be made widely
available to the
public. (RAFI's comment: "Technology
transfer" is a very broad concept.
Terminator seeds in
every foreign aid package? More paper clips for ARS
patent lawyers?)
USDA concludes that Terminator "is a valuable technology."
Ironically,
the agency promotes Terminator as a "green"
technology that will prevent
gene flow from transgenic
plants.
"We reject the notion
that Terminator is a biosafety bandage for GM
crops with
leaky genes, but even if it were, biosafety at the expense of
food security is unacceptable," concludes RAFI's Silvia
Ribeiro.
Last year the FAO's
Panel of Eminent Experts on Ethics in Food and
Agriculture concluded that Terminator seeds are unethical.
When heads of
state meet at FAO's World Food Summit Five
Years Later in Rome, 9-15
November, they will have the
opportunity to re-affirm that finding, and
recommend
that member nations ban the technology. In keeping with its
image as a rogue, isolationist state in international treaty
negotiations on global warming and biological weapons,
the US also
appears to stand alone on Terminator.
********
Delta & Pine Land
(Mississippi, USA) is the world's 9th largest seed
corporation, with revenues of $301 million in 2000. The
company has
joint ventures and/or subsidiaries
in North America, Brazil, Argentina,
China,
Mexico, Paraguay, South Africa, Australia, and China.
RAFI is an international civil
society organization based in Canada. We
are dedicated
to the conservation and sustainable use of biodiversity
and to the socially responsible development of technologies
useful to
rural societies.
For further information on this news
release:
Hope Shand, RAFI: hope@rafi.org,
919 960-5223
Michael Sligh, RAFI-USA
(member of USDA's Ag Biotech Advisory
Committee),:
msligh@rafiusa.org (919) 542-1396
Update: Congress Votes to Open Arctic Refuge to Oil
Drilling.
By Passing Energy Bill,
Congress Turns It's Back on
Conservation.
On Wednesday night, the U.S. House
of Representatives
passed a massive energy bill that
fails to promote
a clean and secure energy future for
the U.S. Despite
faxes from over 4,000 Clean Car
Campaign Action Network
activists urging Congress to
oppose the bill unless
it was improved, the energy
bill's passage amounts
to a giveaway to big oil
companies and the auto industry.
***************************
YOU CAN HELP IMMEDIATELY BY SPREADING THE WORD
ABOUT
ACTION NETWORK:
Visit http://actionnetwork.org/ct/3dqD.H51uqJb/
and invite your friends and family to take action online
for the environment. There is no time like the present.
***************************
BAD ENERGY BILL
PASSES HOUSE:
Specifically, the energy bill would
open the Arctic
National Wildlife Refuge, one of the
most pristine
wilderness areas on the planet, to oil
drilling, and
would ease restrictions on oil drilling on
other public
lands. It also would give away over $30
billion in
tax breaks to the oil, gas and nuclear
industries.
What the bill will NOT do is meaningfully
address energy
conservation. Tax credits for
fuel-efficient vehicles
were not improved as we had
hoped, thereby not assuring
that public health will be
protected or that large
amounts of the credits will not
flow to inefficient
vehicles. Also, auto industry
supporters defeated an
amendment to increase the fuel
efficiency standard
for SUVs from 20.7 mpg to 27.5 mpg.
Raising fuel efficiency
standards would reduce U.S. oil
consumption by up to
1 million barrels a day. That's
more than three times
the amount of oil per day that
would be extracted from
the Arctic National Wildlife
Refuge.
THE FIGHT IS NOT OVER:
While passage of the energy bill was a defeat for
American
consumers and the environment, the fight to
adopt a
balanced energy policy is not over. The Senate
next
takes up the energy debate this fall; be assured
the
Clean Car Campaign will alert you when your help is
needed.
***************************
AGAIN, YOU CAN HELP BY SPREADING THE WORD
ABOUT ACTION
NETWORK:
Visit http://actionnetwork.org/ct/3dqD.H51uqJb/
and invite your friends and family to take action online
for the environment. Every activist makes a difference.
***************************
HOW DID YOUR REPRESENTATIVE VOTE?
Arctic Drilling ("AYES" opposed Arctic Drilling - "NOES"
supported Arctic Drilling)
http://clerkweb.house.gov/cgi-bin/vote.exe?year=2001&rollnumber=317)
Fuel Efficiency Standards for
SUVs ("AYES" supported
increased fuel efficiency
standards - "NOES" opposed
increased fuel efficiency
standards)
http://clerkweb.house.gov/cgi-bin/vote.exe?year=2001&rollnumber=311
Final Vote on Energy Bill
("AYES" supported final Energy
bill - "NOES" opposed
final energy bill)
http://clerkweb.house.gov/cgi-bin/vote.exe?year=2001&rollnumber=320
****************************
* WILD
ALERT
* Monday, August 6, 2001
****************************
Ignoring public opinion and a multi-year public process, the
Bush
Administration has ordered the National Park
Service to re-open its
decision to phase out snowmobiles
in Yellowstone and Grand Teton
National
Parks. Please tell the Park Service to uphold the existing
policy -- http://www.wilderness.org/takeaction/?step=2&item=573 The
comment period is extremely short, ending August 14th.
ADMINISTRATION BACKPEDDLING
This past July, the Bush Administration backed away from its
commitment to protect Yellowstone and Grand Teton from
the damage
caused by snowmobiles, by settling a lawsuit
brought by the
International Snowmobile Manufacturers
Association. As a result, the
Park Service has been
ordered to re-open its decision to phase-out
snowmobiles
-- and reconsider speculative advances in "cleaner"
and
"quieter" snowmobile technology.
To do this, the National Park Service is required to prepare
a "Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement" (SEIS)
to
solicit "more public comment." Industry's strong
endorsement of this
process confirms the Bush
Administration's determination to keep
snowmobiles *in*
the park.
This maneuver sets
aside 10 years of scientific analysis, a 3-year
process
to collect public input, 22 public hearings, and the
involvement of 65,000 people who took time to become
involved it the
process.
COMMENT PERIOD IS ONLY 15 DAYS LONG
The SEIS will be completed in just 15 months and the first
opportunity to voice your opinion is right now, before
August 14,
2001. (The comment period only
opened on July 31st.)
TAKE
ACTION
Please write to the Park Service (sample letter
below) and tell them
to uphold the existing policy to
phase-out snowmobiles from
Yellowstone and Grand Teton
National Parks. Send a message from
http://www.wilderness.org/takeaction/?step=2&item=573
or send your
comments directly.
**It's important to PERSONALIZE YOUR
MESSAGE so the Park Service
counts them as individual
responses.** Tell the Park Service that:
- You object to the NPS plan to conduct a Supplemental EIS
on winter
use at Yellowstone and Grand Teton.
- Ten years of study have proven that snowmobiles harm
wildlife and
threaten public health and safety.
- Uphold the existing plan and begin implementing it
immediately.
Send your comments
to:
Winter Use Plan, Superintendent's Office
Grand Teton National Park, P.O. Drawer 170
Moose, WY 83012
EMAIL:
yell_winter_use@nps.gov (insert "Attn: Winter Use Plan" in the
subject line and include your name and address)
***SAMPLE
LETTER***
I care deeply about
the future of Yellowstone and Grand Teton
National
Parks.
I object to the National
Park Service's plan to conduct a
Supplemental
Environmental Impact Statement on winter use of
snowmobiles in Yellowstone and Grand Teton. I
believe that in 10
years of study, scientists and
professional land managers proved that
snowmobiles are
harming wildlife and threatening public health and
safety. Please uphold the existing plan and immediately
begin to
implement the well-researched decision of the
Park Service to phase
out snowmobiles from these parks.
Sincerely,
***************************************************************
For a full list of Action Items, visit
http://www.wilderness.org/whatcan/takeaction.htm
***************************************************************
An archive of past Wildalerts can be found at
http://www.wilderness.org/wildalert/wildalerts.htm
***************************************************************
WildAlert is an email action alert system brought to you
by The
Wilderness Society to keep you apprised of
threats to our wildlands --
in the field and in
Washington. WildAlert messages include updates
along with clear, concise actions you can take to protect
America's
last wild places. You are welcome
to forward Wildalerts to all those
interested in saving
America's wildlands.
FEEDBACK:
If you need to get in contact with the owner of the list,
(if you have trouble unsubscribing, or have questions about
the list
itself) send email to <action@tws.org>.
TO SUBSCRIBE: If you have been
forwarded this message and would like
to subscribe to
the list, visit
http://www.wilderness.org/forms/subscribe.htm or send a
message to
wildalert@tws.org with 'SUBSCRIBE' in the
subject line.
Founded in 1935,
The Wilderness Society works to protect America's
wilderness and to develop a nation-wide network of wild
lands through
public education, scientific analysis and
advocacy. Our goal is to
ensure that future
generations will enjoy the clean air and water,
wildlife, beauty and opportunities for recreation and
renewal that
pristine forests, rivers, deserts and
mountains provide. To take
action on behalf of wildlands
today, visit our website at
http://www.wilderness.org
========================================
Natural Resources Defense Council's
CALIFORNIA ACTIVIST NETWORK
ACTION ALERT
NRDC's California Activist Network was formed to mobilize
and provide
action tools to Californians and others concerned with
protecting the
state's extraordinary wealth of natural treasures and the
health of
its citizens.
August 7, 2001
========================================
In This Issue:
--Action
alerts--
1. Urge your representative to oppose the Army's expansion into
endangered California desert tortoise habitat
2. Tell the Bush
administration to uphold the rule preserving
California's -- and the
nation's -- last wild national forests
======================================================
You will also
find these alerts in NRDC'S Earth Action Center, which
includes tools for
taking action easily online, at
http://www.nrdc.org/action
(Please
do not reply to this message; see the instructions below for
how to
unsubscribe or contact NRDC with questions or comments.)
=============
Action alerts
=============
1. Urge your representative to
oppose the Army's expansion into
endangered California desert tortoise
habitat
Last week the House Armed Services Committee approved an
amendment to
the Defense department spending bill that would give the U.S.
Army
110,000 acres of public lands and critical desert tortoise habitat for
expanded tank training exercises. The bill would add this area to the
Army's sprawling 642,000-acre Fort Irwin National Training Center in
California's Mojave Desert.
The proposed expansion area
includes 45,000 acres of Wilderness Study
Areas -- home to desert bighorn
sheep, sacred Native American sites
and part of the historic Old Spanish
Emigrant Trail -- that would be
sacrificed to tank maneuvers. Tanks would
also overrun irreplaceable
habitat for the threatened desert tortoise --
California's state
reptile -- including thousands of acres designated as
"critical" for
its survival. What's more, the bill would "fast-track" the
expansion,
giving these lands to the Army before it complies with
environmental
laws, including the National Environmental Policy Act and the
Endangered Species Act.
The bill will be sent to the House floor
shortly after Congress
returns from its August recess.
== What to do
==
Send a message to your representative urging him or her to oppose this
devastating legislation and to demand that environmental laws be
complied with before any expansion is authorized. If you live in Rep.
Susan Davis' district (CA-49), please thank her for raising concerns
in
the Armed Services Committee over the legislation's process and
timing for
transferring land to the Army for the Ft. Irwin expansion.
== Contact
information ==
You can email or fax your representative directly from NRDC's
Earth
Action Center at http://www.nrdc.org/action. If you prefer
to call
your representative, the Capitol Switchboard number is 202-224-3121.
2. Tell the Bush administration to uphold the rule preserving
California's -- and the nation's -- last wild national forests
This
past January the outgoing Clinton administration adopted a
landmark rule
banning logging and roadbuilding in over 58 million
acres of wild roadless
areas in our national forests -- including
more than four million acres here
in California. Since then, however,
the Bush administration has launched a
stealth attack on the largest
nationwide public land conservation decision
in America's history.
First, Bush officials delayed implementing the
roadless rule, then
they refused to defend a lawsuit brought by industry and
its allies
challenging the rule. Now, while proclaiming its commitment to
wilderness values, the administration has started a formal process to
gut the rule by allowing individual national forests to opt out of it,
one roadless wildland at a time. That would turn back the clock to the
old piecemeal decision process that allowed millions of pristine acres
to be developed every decade.
Our forest wildlands serve as vital
habitat for threatened and
endangered species, provide priceless
recreational opportunities, and
ensure clean drinking water. The roadless
rule currently protects all
roadless areas from damaging activities
including logging, mining and
oil and gas development. If the
administration's proposed change goes
forward, however, millions of acres of
our last wild lands will be at
risk -- including Alaska's Tongass
rainforest, the heart of the
world's largest remaining temperate rainforest,
and some of
California's own national forests. Already efforts are underway
to
punch new roads and logging cuts into roadless portions of Los Padres
and Six Rivers national forests, and other national forests here are
likely to see similar attacks soon.
An official comment period on
the proposed rule change is currently
underway; comments must be received by
September 10th.
== What to do ==
Send a message to the Forest
Service before the September 10th comment
deadline, insisting that the rule
be implemented -- and defended --
as it now stands.
== Contact
information ==
You can send an official comment directly from NRDC's Earth
Action
Center at http://www.nrdc.org/action. Or use the
contact information
and sample letter below to send your own message, and
please include
your own reasons why protecting these last wild forest lands
from
logging, mining and drilling is important to you.
Roadless ANPR
Comments
USDA-Forest Service - CAT
P.O. Box 221090
Salt Lake City,
Utah 84122
Fax: 801-296-4090
Email: roadless_anpr@fs.fed.us
== Sample letter ==
Subject: Roadless ANPR comments - Preserve the current rule protecting
California's last wild n