|
***************************************
GLOBAL RESPONSE ACTION ALERT #4/01
Stop Gold Mine Expansion / Peru
Sept-Oct 2001
***************************************
"We will
defend this water with our lives.”
-- Julio Marin,
President, Regional Coordinator
of
Watersheds Affected by Mining in Cajamarca (CORECAMI)
In less than
ten years, a rural agricultural and dairy producing region in
northern Peru
has been overwhelmed by a multinational mining operation whose
four open-pit
gold mines are the most profitable in all of South America.
Spread across
25,000 hectares (63,000 acres) of mountaintops, the Yanacocha
Mine is
already the world’s second-largest gold mine, and it intends to keep
growing. The joint-venture company owns mineral rights to an additional
125,000 hectares including Mount Quilish, the main source of water for the
city of Cajamarca.
At the mine sites, huge piles of low-grade ore
are soaked in a toxic cyanide
solution that leaches out the gold and silver
(see box). Although Yanacocha
managers claim cyanide and other
toxic metals cannot escape the mine site
into the watershed, mining expert
Dr. Robert Moran says, “all the sites I’ve
ever worked at experience some
degree of leakage.” Mine contamination has
already resulted in
three major fish kills in area rivers and trout farms.
“People are
troubled about their future and a heavy cloak of anxiety and
profound
concern darkens the spirit of the place and threatens any
meaningful sense
of well-being….There is general agreement that the current
situation in
Cajamarca is unsustainable from a social, economic, and
environmental
perspective,” states the report of an expert mission sent to
the region by
the Ombudsman’s Office of the International Finance
Corporation (IFC), the
private lending arm of the World Bank. The expert
team visited
Cajamarca in response to two formal complaints filed by
Cajamarca citizen
groups.
The first complaint demands investigation and reparations for
mercury
poisoning that affected up to 300 villagers in June
2000. The mercury
leaked from a Yanacocha Mine truck,
contaminating a 40-km. section of
highway, including three villages. The
second complaint demands company
accountability for many negative social,
economic, health and environmental
impacts on the community. Demands include
higher prices for land purchases,
public access to monitoring of water and
air quality, ecosystem
preservation, health services, and citizen
participation in all these
activities. Number One among these demands is no
further expansion.
Saving Mount Quilish (keeLEESH) is the greatest
concern for the city of
Cajamarca. Its 130,000 residents (plus
300,000 in the surrounding areas)
depend on water from Mount Quilish for
drinking and agriculture. The
Yanacocha Mine already owns almost
all of Mount Quilish and refuses to
relinquish its right to mine the
mountain. The IFC, which owns 5% of shares
in the Yanacocha Mine
and provides additional loans, also refuses to define
Mount Quilish
off-limits; it only says that Peruvian and IFC standards for
environmental
impact studies and public consultation will be applied.
For Cajamarca
citizens who are already embattled against the huge, powerful
mine, this is
insufficient assurance. They know the terrifying history of
toxic
spills at gold mines around the world, including the Romanian spill
this
year that killed fish along 250 miles of the Danube River and
tributaries. They know that similar indigenous communities in
Indonesia,
Nevada, Southern California and the Philippines are protesting
environmental
and human rights abuses of Newmont Mining Corporation, the
major shareholder
in the Yanacocha Mine.
REQUESTED
ACTION: A coalition of community defense committees in the
Cajamarca region is asking Global Response members to write to the IFC and
Newmont Mining Corporation, urging them to declare Mount Quilish off-limits
for mining, and to establish policies requiring the participation and
consent of affected communities.
**********************
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
**********************
CYANIDE HEAP LEACH
MINING – This toxic technology makes it possible to
recover gold from very
low-grade ores. Using massive equipment, the miners
dig huge open pits and
crush the rock. Then the ore is heaped on a liner and
sprayed with a dilute
cyanide solution. The cyanide bonds to gold. Miners
recover the
gold and recycle the cyanide solution to the next ore heap.
HOW
DANGEROUS IS IT? – Cyanide poisoning can occur through inhalation,
ingestion, skin or eye contact. In solid form at the size of a
grain of
rice it is lethal to humans; small concentrations kill fish, birds
and
mammals. In the leaching process, cyanide also dissolves
toxic metals such
as arsenic, lead, zinc, uranium, mercury, and cadmium,
allowing them to
contaminate water and soils. Toxic metals accumulate in
living tissue and
are passed through the food chain, causing a host of
illnesses in animals
and humans, including cancer. Acid drainage
from mines continues to
contaminate water decades after the mines are
closed.
COMMUNITIES SAY NO – Citizens are starting to chalk up successes
in their
battles against irresponsible mining. In 1998, the state
of Montana, USA,
passed a ban on all new open pit cyanide process gold
mines. The same year,
the Turkish Supreme Court found in favor of citizens
who claimed that a gold
mine violated their right to a clean environment. In
Canada, citizens
successfully blocked the Windy Craggy gold mine, and in the
USA they stopped
the New World Gold Mine near Yellowstone National Park and
the Crown Jewel
Mine in Washington state. As in Peru, water quality was the
primary
consideration in these successful citizen battles.
WHAT'S
THAT ON YOUR FINGER? – Jewelry comprises about 85% of the gold
market. To produce one gold ring, five or six tons of ore may be
dug up,
crushed, soaked in cyanide, and dumped into tailings pits,
threatening
plant, animal and human life for miles downstream and downwind.
*********************
REQUESTED ACTION: Please send
polite letters to partners in the Yanacocha
mine: Newmont Mining Corporation
and the International Finance Corporation
(the office of the World Bank that
provides loans to the private sector).
· Urge them to commit to
Cajamarca citizens’ demand for no mining operations
on Mount Quilish, the
main source of drinking water for Cajamarca and the
surrounding agricultural
region;
· Demand that both Newmont and the IFC establish policies
requiring the
participation and consent of affected communities in decisions
about new
mine sites and mine expansion. They must comply with
the Rio Declaration on
Environment and Development which states: “…each
individual shall have
appropriate access to information concerning the
environment that is held by
public authorities, including information on
hazardous materials and
activities in their communities, and the opportunity
to participate in
decision-making processes” (Principle 10).
ADDRESSES:
Wayne Murdy, CEO Peter Woicke
Newmont Mining
Corporation Executive Vice President
1700 Lincoln Street International
Finance Corporation
Denver, CO 80203 USA 2121 Pennsylvania Ave, NW
FAX:
303 837-6100 Washington, DC 20433 USA
FAX: 202 974-4359
This Global Response Action was issued at the request of and with
information provided by the Northern Peru Federation of Women’s
Organizations, the Regional Coordinator of Watersheds Affected by Mining in
Cajamarca, the Cajamarca State Federation of Women’s Organizations, the
Cajamarca State Coordinator of Villages Affected by Mining, Oxfam America,
Mineral Policy Center, and Project Underground. Special thanks to George
Blevins for his drawing. For excellent information about mining
and citizen
action campaigns, see these websites: www.mineralpolicy.org ; www.moles.org
;
www.newmont.com ; www.ifc.org/cao ; www.oxfamamerica.org
;
www.globalresponse.org
********************************
Paula Palmer, Executive Director
Global Response
PO Box 7490
Boulder CO 80306
Tel. 303-444-0306
Fax. 303-449-9794
Website: www.globalresponse.org
Mission: Global Response empowers people of all ages,
cultures, and
nationalities to protect the environment by creating
partnerships for
effective citizen action. At the request of
indigenous peoples and
grassroots organizations, Global Response organizes
international
letter-writing campaigns to help communities prevent
environmental
destruction. Global Response involves young people
as well as adults in
these campaigns, to develop in them the values and
skills for global citizen
cooperation and earth stewardship.
NEW! Now you can make
donations online at: http://www.globalresponse.org .
EarthNet News
...a project of the Center for
Environmental Citizenship
September 20, 2001
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As we continue to sort out our complicated emotions following last Tuesday's
tragic events, here at EarthNet we follow the nation's lead and do our best
to
return to normalcy. For me, that's cyber-organizing to make
the world a better
place. This week, stop a pipeline that would
wreak havoc on the Amazonian
rainforest and urge your Representatives to
support the Salmon Planning Act --
long may they spawn. (The
fish, that is, not the politicians!)
Also, in the wake of
the September 11 attacks, the World Bank and IMF announced
they would not
hold their annual meetings in Washington, DC, scheduled for the
end of this
month. Subsequently, most of the organizations that were planning
to protest the meetings have cancelled their corresponding marches and
demonstrations.
--Susie Gorden, EarthNet Editor
mailto:earthnet@envirocitizen.org
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Shadow Congress: Caught in the Act
2. Corporate Corner:
Pipe Dreams
3. Quote of the Week
4. My Bad
5. Eco-Exposure
6.
Jobs, Conferences and Gatherings
7. Activist Phone Book & EarthNet News
Info
SHADOW CONGRESS
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Back in the days of Lewis and Clark, as many as 15 million wild salmon made
the
annual journey from the Pacific Ocean back to the spot where they were
born to
spawn. Today, a meager 10,000 salmon return home to the Snake
River. You can
help ensure their survival when you voice your
support for the Salmon Planning
Act, introduced by Rep. Jim McDermott (D-WA)
this summer. The Act would ensure
that comprehensive "back-up"
plans are in place if the 2000 federal salmon plan
fails to restore salmon
to the Snake River basin, and it authorizes the General
Accounting Office to
conduct studies.
Already 44 co-sponsors have signed on. But
they'll need more than that if
Congress is to successfully save the
salmon!
TAKE ACTION NOW: Urge your
Representatives to cosponsor the Salmon Planning
Act at http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet
FOR MORE INFO: http://www.wildsalmon.org;
http://www.waterchat.com/News/Federal/01/Q3/fed_010726-02.htm
CORPORATE CORNER
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Plans are moving ahead on a controversial pipeline known as the OCP --
Oleoducto de Crudos Pesados -- that would threaten 11 protected areas in the
Ecuadorian rainforest. Current efforts to derail the disastrous
pipeline focus
on the Westdeutsche Landesbank, which is a primary financial
backer of the
plan. The Ecuadorian government closed public
hearings on this issue only 27
days after the release of the Environmental
Impact Survey -- clearly not enough
time to investigate the devastating
consequences this would have on the
country's cloud and rainforests, its
indigenous communities, and several
threatened bird species.
TAKE ACTION NOW: Use the EarthNet Action Center at
http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet
to let the backers know this pipe dream would
be a nightmare.
FOR
MORE INFO: http://www.amazonwatch.org/;
http://www.leastimpact.org/index.shtml;
http://rainforestweb.org/pages/ocp.php
QUOTE OF THE WEEK
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is what you shall do: Love the earth and sun and animals, despise
riches,
give alms to every one that asks, stand up for the stupid and crazy,
devote
your income and labor to others, hate tyrants, argue not concerning
God, have
patience and indulgence toward the people, take off your hat to
nothing known
or unknown ... reexamine all you have been told at school or
church or in any
book, dismiss whatever insults your own soul, and your very
flesh shall be a
great poem and have the richest fluency.
-- Walt
Whitman, author, in preface to Leaves of Grass
GLIMMER OF HOPE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Back in March, we wrote about General Electric (GE) and its toxic legacy of
dumping more than a million tons of PCBs into the Hudson River in New York.
GE's actions destroyed 200 miles of river and created the largest Superfund
site in the country. Well this summer, EPA Secretary Christine
Todd Whitman
announced that GE would have to pay for dredging the Hudson
River. This is
another example of how your efforts
work. Even when the big guys spend
millions to shirk their
responsibilities, concerted citizen action can make a
difference. So keep on taking action at Corporate Corner!
ECO-EXPOSURE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
You've got a vision of an ecologically sustainable future and the National
Wildlife Federation's Campus Ecology Fellowship Program offers an
opportunity
to pursue it. Students -- under or grad level -- are eligible to
apply for the
fellowship, which provides practical experience in the
conservation field, as
well as a grant and national recognition.The next
deadline for apps is November
15 -- apply online at http://www.nwf.org/campusecology/fellowships/apply.html
MY BAD
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Two editions past, I announced the dates for the upcoming ECOnference as
September 19-21. The correct dates are OCTOBER
19-21. Sorry for the mix-up.
FOR MORE INFO: http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/events/detail.asp?id=883
Want to get something off your chest? Send your letters
to
mailto:earthnet@envirocitizen.org
We reserve the right to edit for
length, clarity, and purpose.
JOBS AND INTERNSHIPS
------------------------------
These are a sampling of the over 200
environmental and activist jobs and
internships listed at
www.envirocitizen.org/enet/jobs/index.asp!
Clean Water Action seeks a
Community Organizer in Houston, TX. Find the job
description at
http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/jobs/detail.asp?id=3426
The Desert Research Station is looking for a Research Station Intern
near
Barstow, CA. Find the job description at
http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/jobs/detail.asp?id=3419
The National Wildlife Federation is hiring a Population and
Environment
Specialists in Ann Arbor, MI. Find the job
description at
http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/jobs/detail.asp?id=3403
CONFERENCES, GATHERINGS AND VIEWINGS
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
All events listed at http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/events/index.asp
WHAT: Leadership Skills Training
WHERE: Boston,
MA
WHEN: September 29, 2001
FOR MORE INFO: http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/events/detail.asp?id=913
WHAT: Brownfields 2001 Conference
WHERE: Chicago, IL
WHEN: September 24-26, 2001
FOR MORE INFO: http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/events/detail.asp?id=889
WHAT: 16th Annual Wild Rockies Rendezvous
WHERE: Missoula, MT
WHEN: September 27-29
FOR MORE INFO: http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/events/detail.asp?id=901
ACTIVIST PHONE BOOK
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
U.S. Capitol Switchboard: 202.224.3121
White House Comment Line:
202.456.1111
EarthNet Action Center: http://congress.nw.dc.us/cec
White
House Address: 1600 Pennsylvania Ave, Washington, DC 20500
Senate Address:
US Senate, Washington, DC 20510
House Address: US House of Representatives,
Washington, DC 20515
**Look up e-mail addresses in a comprehensive
congressional directory at
http://congress.nw.dc.us/cec/congdir.html
or http://www.vote-smart.org/ce
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Write your own short articles for submission to EarthNet. We are
particularly
interested in articles about student activism on your campus.
The email
accounts for EarthNet News are:
For general comments:
mailto:earthnet@envirocitizen.org
For article submissions or ideas:
mailto:submissions@envirocitizen.org
Submit Jobs/Internships/Volunteer
listings at
http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/jobs/add.asp.
Submit Events at http://www.envirocitizen.org/enet/events/add.asp.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To subscribe to our listserv, EarthNet News, go to
http://www.envirocitizen.org/subscribe.html,
or send an email to
mailto:earthnet-request@earthsystems.org with the subject subscribe
September 19, 2001
Dear NRDC Earth
Activist,
Our hearts go out to those of you in our extended family of
600,000
Members and online activists who have suffered the loss of loved
ones
or colleagues in the terrible events of September 11th.
As you
may know, NRDC is headquartered in New York City, with one of
our field
offices in Washington, D.C. Thankfully, our staff and
immediate families are
all safe and accounted for. But we have friends
who are missing, and we
share in the grief that has stricken all
Americans in the aftermath of this
tragedy.
I wanted to share a few thoughts with you about the work that
lies
ahead for NRDC. With your ongoing help, we are determined to put our
unique expertise to work for the common good in this time of crisis.
As Americans, we must now join together in shaping a strong response
to terrorism. For NRDC that means advocating policies that will
immediately begin reducing our nation's dependence on oil, whether
imported or domestic. That is the single most important thing that we,
as environmentalists, can do to ensure America's national security and
environmental security.
America's unchecked consumption of oil has
become a national Achilles
heel. It constrains our military options in the
face of terror. It
leaves our economy dangerously vulnerable to price
shocks. It invites
environmental degradation, ecological disasters, and
potentially
catastrophic climate change.
Don't be surprised in the
days ahead to hear some in Washington call
for a massive increase in
domestic oil drilling in order to achieve
national security. They ignore one
crucial fact: our nation simply
doesn't have enough oil reserves to drill
our way to self-sufficiency
or to affect oil prices, which are set on the
world market. We control
only 3 percent of the world's oil reserves -- a
mere drop in the
bucket -- but we consume a staggering 25 percent of the
world's oil
supply.
Even if we developed every potential oil deposit
in America --
including the Arctic Wildlife Refuge -- we'd still be
importing oil,
still be paying worldwide prices for domestic oil, and still
be
leaving ourselves vulnerable to supply disruptions.
Is there an
alternative? Yes. We can reduce our out-of-control
appetite for fossil
fuels. We can rely on smarter and cleaner ways to
power our economy. For 30
years, NRDC has been proving that energy
efficiency and alternative energy
technologies can save billions of
barrels of oil, while benefiting our
health, our pocketbooks and our
environment.
I want you to know
that, in the months to come, NRDC will be a leading
advocate for an energy
future that reduces this dangerous addiction to
oil and increases our
reliance on cleaner alternatives spawned by
American ingenuity. That is our
very best hope -- our only hope --
for getting us on a
self-reliant energy path toward lasting national
and environmental security.
In the meantime, I hope you are able to take extra time with those you
love, and to begin the healing we all so urgently need.
Sincerely,
John H. Adams
President
NRDC
==========
About NRDC
==========
The Natural Resources Defense Council is a nonprofit
environmental
organization with over 500,000 members nationwide and a staff
of
scientists, attorneys and environmental experts. Our mission is to
protect the planet's wildlife and wild places and ensure a safe and
healthy environment for all living things.
For more information
about NRDC or how to become a member of NRDC,
please contact us at:
Natural Resources Defense Council
40 West 20th Street
New York,
NY 10011
212-727-4511 (voice) / 212-727-1773 (fax)
General email:
nrdcinfo@nrdc.org
Earth Action email: nrdcaction@nrdc.org
http://www.nrdc.org
Lost in America, Closer to Home
9/19/01
Dear Friends,
We have made it to Columbus, Ohio for the night
and are staying just a
couple of blocks from the state capitol building
where Governor Rhodes gave
the order on May 4, 1970, to send the National
Guard to Kent State. There
they opened fire on hundreds of unarmed students,
killing four and wounding
many others.
Few dared to call it a
terrorist act committed by the state of Ohio… but,
there I go again. Off
message! Stay focused on the main themes, Mike:
“AMERICA UNITED!” “SMOKE ‘EM
OUTTA THEIR HOLES, HUNT ‘EM DOWN, AND GIT
‘EM!” “THE SLEEPING GIANT HAS BEEN
AROUSED!” and “REMEMBER THE POSTER IN
THE OLD WEST: ‘WANTED: DEAD OR
ALIVE!’”
I have a question to all the war hawks out there: When you
listen and look
at our Commander-in-Chief, do you really think THIS is the
guy who is going
to kick some major league ass? I’m just asking all you
conservative drum
beaters out there -- man, you must be *embarrassed* that
this is the best
we have to offer.
I know we are all supposed to be
supportive of Mr. Bush, at the moment, but
has it dawned on anyone that he
is not, in fact, the “president?” I hate to
bring up a thorny subject, but
this is the man who *lost* the election. He
got the *least* number of votes
between the two major party candidates. His
brother oversaw a rigged vote in
Florida.
I am so, so sorry to bring this up now, but the tragedy of the
past week is
EXACTLY the kind of horrible circumstance many Americans feared
we’d find
ourselves in -- A NATIONAL CRISIS UNDER A LEADER WHO IS NOT THERE
BY THE
WILL OF THE PEOPLE. It is a tribute to the goodwill of the American
public
that they have rallied behind George W. Bush as best they can, ‘cause
he
and his fake flight jacket is all we got right now in the Oval Office.
Someone needs to get in charge and propose some real solutions to
bringing
the perpetrators to justice and preventing this -- as best as
possible --
from happening again. Instead, what we have is Bush speaking
like a wind-up
doll, mouthing a bunch of nonsense clichés, repeating them
over and over
and over.
But occasionally his batteries run out --
and he goes off on some
unintelligible tangent. You can see his handlers
desperately trying to cut
him off and whisk him away. You watch in awe and
you ask the question that
none of us even wants to contemplate right now,
and that no one will dare
to ask, so I might as well take the hit and be the
one: THIS is the
Commander-in-Chief of the most powerful country on earth?
Who amongst you
feels secure tonight? What enemy is going to be afraid of
*this* guy?
Bush keeps calling what we are in “a war.” Has anyone told
him that the
more he keeps using this word, the more HE puts US in jeopardy?
A “war”
implies that two sides are participating in an action to kill as
many of
the other side as possible. Bush and the pundits use the word like
it’s a
one-sided deal, like we’re going to be the only ones doing the
bombing. War
means we bomb them, then they bomb us. That’s what war is, you
idiots. We
strafe Afghanistan, then the terrorists drop a canister of
chemical weapons
in the New York subway. We send in a group of commandos and
wipe out a camp
of Muslims, they take out the Sears Tower.
All of
you who are screaming for war: are you prepared to pay the price, to
take
thousands of more casualties? Because, my big, macho-talking friends,
THAT
is what this kind of war would be like. America is a complex and open
society with a massive and intricate infrastructure that is fragile and
vulnerable and susceptible to easy attack and disruption. IT CAN BE BROUGHT
DOWN WITH A BOXCUTTER. Let me repeat that:
IT CAN BE BROUGHT DOWN --
IT CAN BE BROUGHT TO A TOTAL STANDSTILL -- BY A
BOXCUTTER!
Nearly a
week with no stock market, no commercial television, no
professional sports,
three days with no planes in the air (for the first
time since 1911), no
airports open, the country essentially shut down. A
week later and the phone
lines still don’t all work. A boxcutter, folks! Do
not be misled into
thinking he with the biggest missile is going to win
this “war.”
We
will never be able to protect all of us from this kind of terrorism.
Back
and forth, more buildings bombed, more planes downed, more innocent
American
lives lost. When does this end? After we have killed every
terrorist? When
exactly is THAT scheduled to happen? Or is it just when we
kill Osama bin
Laden, *then* we win the war? Are you serious? We couldn’t
even assassinate
Hitler during a massive World War that lasted 6 years!
Bush now says
this is “a war against the evil people in the world.” Oh,
really? THAT war!
Yeah, we should be able to defeat “evil,” oh, sometime in
the next
millennium or two. Get a grip. “War” is not going to get the
justice we
demand or make us more safe. You know it and I know it. There is
a different
way to go, and I will lay it out in a later letter, but to
simplify it for
now and put it in a nutshell, it goes like this:
One billion people on
this planet have no clean drinking water. Two billion
have no electricity.
Three billion have never made a phone call from their
home. We have the
money and the people-power to alter ALL of this. We also
have the moral
imperative to stop supporting repressive regimes and
corporations who
exploit these people.
When we decide to help improve these billions of
people’s lives, we will
pull the rug out from under the terrorists who need
those they send to
their deaths to be poor and exploited and angry at us.
The
multi-millionaire bin Laden isn’t going to give up HIS life!
When all the people in the Middle East have food on the table, a decent
home, a good job, and democratic control over their own lives, who among
them is going to be convinced to sacrifice his life by crashing himself
into a tall office building?
Sure, there will always be those who go
insane and kill without reason. The
British saw that in a Dunblane
schoolyard, we saw it in Oklahoma City.
There will always be religious
fanatics willing to kill and be killed
because they believe God has so
ordered them. Ask the families of the
assassinated women’s clinics’ doctors
in Buffalo and Florida about those
willing to commit evil in the name of
religion in America.
There IS a way to protect us from further attack,
to lift the rest of the
world out of its misery, but it requires some smarts
and some guts, two
things in short supply in Washington these days.
After arriving in Columbus, Kathleen and I met up with one of our best
friends from Flint, Al Hirvela. Al teaches at Ohio State. He was just the
shot in the arm I needed this week. He, Kathleen, I and a bunch of others
all used to put out an alternative newspaper in Flint many years ago and we
miss being around each other in times like these. We miss being able to
talk and try to figure out what it all means -- and what we should be doing
about it. Al is a Quaker and a pacifist, and sitting in the Big Boy last
night talking to him was the kind of grounding experience I needed after
four days on the road.
My publisher called two nights ago to ask
where I might end up for the
evening, as my editor wanted to ship me a copy
of my new book, just off the
press. This was bittersweet news -- I have
dedicated this book to Al, and
to think that I would be there when he opened
it up and saw his name on
that dedication page was indeed a lucky privilege,
a cool moment I never
expected to have.
But the book publisher also
gave me this news: They are “delaying” the
release of my book due to the
events of the past week. No doubt, this book
is going to ruffle some
feathers, and in light of the attack in New York,
the book suddenly gave
everyone connected to it (including me) the
heebie-jeebies. What a feeling
to have in a free country!
In a way, though, I was relieved with their
decision -- I have absolutely
ZERO interest in going out on a book tour this
week. Even though I have
much I would like to say -- opinions and thoughts
that are NOT being heard
in the media right now -- I just can’t go out there
and have my name
attached to something that is “on sale” (I have asked our
webmaster to
remove anything from our site that leads one to purchase any of
my films,
TV shows or books).
I am very proud of this book, and I
hoped it would stimulate a lot of
discussion on various topics. I don’t know
now when it will come out --
maybe next month, maybe next year. In the
meantime, I will continue to
communicate on the Web and speak to any media
outlet that will listen to --
and report uncensored -- what I have to say
about the tragic situation in
which we are now immersed.
I can’t
believe all the incredible letters you are sending me -- over
41,000 letters
in the last week. I am so sorry I cannot respond to each of
you. I have
scrolled down through the subject headings and read a few of
the letters and
it is clear I am not alone in my sadness over this tragedy
or in the anger I
have for what is being proposed by our leaders. I will
print these letters
and let our elected officials see what the REST of
America is thinking about
the idea of “war.”
We are now driving across Ohio toward West Virginia
and Pennsylvania. On
the radio, NPR is running a history report on Osama bin
Laden. We are told
that he comes from a wealthy family and that they are the
main builders for
the Saudi royal family. They’ve remodeled palaces and
built holy sites.
Their construction projects are everywhere. Kathleen turns
to me, and with
one word sums up the kind of low-life we are talking about
here.
“Contractors,” she says. “Bin Laden is a contractor.” Indeed, it
all made
sense.
Someone at NPR tracked me down on the road and asked
me to stop by the
nearest NPR station and read my letters over the air. I
agreed, but I got
choked up reading them into the microphone. I wonder if
they will even
broadcast them. I hope they do, as I felt that my reading of
them conveyed
more of a real and human sense of what I am trying to say and
what I am
seeing on this drive across America.
Later in the evening,
my letters go out on an NPR program called “The
Connection” from WBUR in
Boston. More mail pours in. On the Pennsylvania
Turnpike we pass through
nearby Shanksville, PA, where the United flight
went down. The girl at the
newsstand counter in the rest stop says it was
“just three miles down the
road.” Close enough for all of them to hear it
crash. Her voice shakes as
she tells me this. A car parked in front of the
door has a temporary
“Cemetery Pass” sitting on its dash.
I think of Barbara Olson, the
conservative commentator and wife of the man
who argued Bush’s case for
installation in front of the courts last year. I
have been on “Politically
Incorrect” with her on a couple of occasions. She
was always a warm and
friendly person. She was on that plane, on her way to
do that show.
Monday night, the program went on, and Bill Maher left a chair on the
stage
empty, in her honor. I agreed with her on nothing, and I cried when I
saw
that empty chair. She was a human being who deserved to live. She was an
American who loved her country. Maybe I should have gotten to know her
better, instead of just ignoring her because of her politics. She was a
year younger than me…
We will make it home to New York, sometime
tonight…
Yours,
Michael Moore
mmflint@aol.com
www.michaelmoore.com
CTo: All
activists
From: Randi Spivak, Executive Director
Date: September 20, 2001
Subject: Conservation In a Time of Crisis
While Congress and the Administration mobilize to address
terrorism,
both the Congressional leadership and the Administration have
signaled
that they intend to complete FY 2002 "non emergency"
business. The
schedule is still fluid, but work on the Interior
Appropriations bill
which funds the Forest Service and the Farm Bill will
likely be
considered in mid October. However, important decisions
about these
bills are being made now.
The September 11th tragedy is
still fresh and painful. Citizens are
giving support - emotionally,
financially and physically - to help with
relief
efforts. Still, within just the next few weeks, Congress also
will be making decisions that affect wildlands. It is imperative
that
the conservation community have a strong voice in these decisions.
Amid the talk of national defense and preparedness, the Administration
or members of Congress could use Tuesday's tragedy to advance an anti-
environmental agenda in the name of national security. Some lawmakers
may be tempted to use current events as a rationale for justifying
President Bush's domestic energy policy. An energy policy that
proposes
to reduce U.S. dependence on foreign oil by suspending
environmental
laws, accelerating construction of biomass plants fed by trees
logged to
reduce hazardous fuels and drilling and mining in environmentally
sensitive areas. Congress may also try to pass Fast Track
authority in
the name of national security and maximum flexibility for the
Administration.
Similar attempts were made in WWII when timber
interests pressed
Congress to open up the Olympic National Park in
Washington State to log
giant Sitka spruce to manufacture military aircraft.
Conservationists
rose up against exploiting this national treasure. Then
Interior
Secretary Harold Ickes challenged the War Production Board about
the
necessity of logging the Olympic before all other alternatives were
exhausted. Ultimately, the War Board could not prove that the
Sitka
spruce was needed and Olympic National Park was saved.
We strongly believe that it remains our responsibility as activists to
speak out for wildlands and against proposals that could destroy them in
the name of national security or meeting domestic energy needs.
Conservation is likely the quickest, most efficient way to address our
dependence on foreign oil. And while it is important to unite as
a
nation, it is important to speak out about appropriate and inappropriate
responses to Tuesday's terrorist attacks.
We encourage you to call
your representative and share your views.
Please also
respectfully request their the leadership to maintain
protections for
forests and wildlands, ensure that Fast Track authority
does not get pushed
through, and oppose any other policies that
undermine environmental
protections and labor rights in the name of
energy production or national
security. In the past, we made the right
choice. We do
not have to destroy our country's greatest assets to meet
our national
security needs. Conservation and renewable energy sources,
not increased
fossil fuel production, is the key to America's long term
security. Regrettably the current Congress has so far been
unwilling to
chart that course. This is their and our second
chance.
The love of this country's wild rivers, mountains and forests
are also
reflections of the enduring values that Americans hold
dear.
Randi Spivak, Executive Director
American Lands Alliance
mailto:randispivak@earthlink.net
Steve Holmer
Campaign Coordinator
American Lands
726 7th Street
SE
Washington, D.C. 20003
202/547-9105
202/547-9213 fax
mailto:wafcdc@americanlands.org
http://www.americanlands.org
********************************
* WILD ALERT
* Thursday,
September 20, 2001
********************************
In response to
our WildAlert last Friday, we've received an outpouring
of messages, some
tragically sad, others offering assistance. What is
clear to us
is that, like many others across the country, the
WildAlert community is
deeply affected by this tragedy.
It is a time for mourning and grieving,
but also a time for healing
and unity. Indeed, we are proud of
the way in which citizens and
elected leaders alike have come together in a
common purpose of
helping each other through this national
crisis.
ARCTIC NEWS
As some of you may be aware,
some oil industry lobbyists have been
trying to link the issue of arctic oil
to our national security,
cynically using the attacks on America as an
excuse to open the Arctic
Refuge to oil drilling.
But
yesterday Sen. Frank Murkowski, the chief proponent of Arctic oil
drilling
in the Senate, announced in a statement that he would **NOT
** attempt to
add an Arctic oil drilling provision to the Defense
Authorization
bill. It is still unclear whether the Senate will bring
up energy
legislation this fall, however, Sen. Murkowski has pledged
to try to attach
Arctic drilling language to such legislation.
Drilling for
oil in the Arctic Refuge will do little or nothing to
ensure America's
energy security. The U.S. Geological Survey
estimates that there
is little more than a six-month supply of oil in
the Refuge. More
importantly, it will take nearly 10 years before the
oil begins to flow.
These facts aside, this is not the time for Congress to take up
controversial political issues that threaten to unravel the remarkable
and inspirational outpourings of courage and purpose that unite our
nation. There will be another time - a better time - for Congress
to
debate the nation's energy future. However, that time is not
today.
Sincerely,
Bill Meadows
President
The Wilderness
Society
***************************************************************
For a full list of Action Items, visit
http://www.wilderness.org/whatcan/takeaction.htm
***************************************************************
An archive of past Wildalerts can be found at
http://www.wilderness.org/wildalert/wildalerts.htm
***************************************************************
WildAlert is an email action alert system brought to you by The
Wilderness Society to keep you apprised of threats to our wildlands --
in the field and in Washington. WildAlert messages include
updates
along with clear, concise actions you can take to protect America's
last wild places. You are welcome to forward Wildalerts to all
those
interested in saving America's wildlands.
FEEDBACK: If you
need to get in contact with the owner of the list,
(if you have trouble
unsubscribing, or have questions about the list
itself) send email to <action@tws.org>.
TO SUBSCRIBE: If you have been forwarded this message and would like
to subscribe to the list, visit
http://www.wilderness.org/forms/subscribe.htm
or send a message to
wildalert@tws.org with 'SUBSCRIBE' in the subject line.
Founded in 1935, The Wilderness Society works to protect America's
wilderness and to develop a nation-wide network of wild lands through
public education, scientific analysis and advocacy. Our goal is
to
ensure that future generations will enjoy the clean air and water,
wildlife, beauty and opportunities for recreation and renewal that
pristine forests, rivers, deserts and mountains provide. To take
action
on behalf of wildlands today, visit our website at
http://www.wilderness.org
Positive Energy
September 17th - 23rd
v1.13
Time for the highlight of your week - Greenpeace's
Clean
Energy Now Campaign Weekly Good News
update - "Positive Energy"
>> California Power Authority Invests In Dirty Energy!?!
In the name of "firming" up their new purchases of green
power, the
California Power Authority announced it will
move forward with intentions to
purchase 2000 MW of gas
fired peaker plants to be online for the summer of
2002.
The Authority also intends to bring 1000 MW of
renewable
energy online, mostly in the form wind and bio-mass plants,
but it has further issued a new request for bids.
Greenpeace is
committed to making sure the ratio reverses
to a mix of renewables ahead of
gas.
October 5th is your next chance to tell the CPA in
person
that we can't afford any more global warming gases, at a
public
hearing in San Francisco, so join Greenpeace in the
fight for our future!
Send a fax to the Authority explicitly demanding sunshine
planning
and clean energy!
Take Action Now:
http://www.cleanenergynow.org/takeaction/cpa.html
>> UPEX '01 : The Photovoltaic Experience Conference
The Solar Electric Power Association's annual Expo will
take place
in Sacramento from September 30th through
October 4th. This is a
great opportunity to learn more
about the future of photovoltaics, energy
efficiency, and
renewable power in residential, commercial, and government
settings from some of the industry leaders. The Expo is
open
to the public on Sunday the 30th from noon until 5 pm,
including public
workshops from 1pm to 4pm. There will
also be a tour of SMUD, Cal
Solar, and the PVUSA site on
Wednesday.
For more information visit
http://www.SolarElectricPower.org
>> The 7th Annual San Francisco Cancer Industry Tour
Join the Toxic Links Coalition in highlighting the links
between
dirty power and our health on their annual cancer
causing industry tour,
Wednesday, October 3rd.
The tour will target PG&E's
polluting of local communities;
Bechtel, for international nuclear pollution
and their bid
to privatize water supply worldwide;
Chevron, for
polluting refineries in Richmond as well as
environmental and human rights
violations in Nigeria;
and Solem & Associates, the public relations firm
that
works to hide their messes.
Help the Toxic Links
Coalition expose this filth and
make a case for clean, renewable energy.
Rally begins at 12pm at PG&E Corporate Offices
77 Beale Street
(Between Market & Mission, Embarcadero BART/Muni).
Sponsored by the Toxic Links Coalition
(510) 601-4040 ext. 302 or
(415) 243-9301 ext. 14
ULSTER GREEN ACTION
EMAIL UPDATE
Friday, 01/09/21 Autumn Equinox
1) I have been struggling to clearly
and publicly express my
thoughts and feelings, in measured words, regarding
the WTC
attack and the aftermath.
Mostly the aftermath. Particularly
the rush to judgment,
hatred, and revenge -- with the media and politicians
beating
the war drums incessantly -- with nary a voice speaking up for
peace, reason, understanding, or patience.
Surely, regarding the
attack itself -- were we not all UNITED in
shock, disbelief, horror, fear,
sorrow, frustration, concern,
sympathy, pain, depression, and, eventually,
overload and
numbness? But to say, or accept, that all America stands united
regarding what to DO NOW, or how we all FEEL about the
juggernaut to
war, has me most distressed and feeling helpless,
as if NOTHING I could say
or do could, or would, stop the blind,
headlong, impetuous inevitability --
the forgone conclusion --
that we were ALREADY in "America's New WAR," as
CNN trumpeted
within mere days, as if the Constitution had granted to THEM,
and not Congress, the power to declare war!
I watched the TV from 9
AM, Tuesday morning, 9/11, almost
continuously, (or listened to the radio
while in the car) and
kept hoping for some voices of wisdom and context. But
there was
NO explanation or discussion of the many seething grievances
people have against us; of atrocities done in OUR name over
decades that
have killed or wounded MILLIONS of innocents around
the globe; of the forces
of repression and rapine we have
unleashed ourselves; of tin-horn dictators
we've propped up
against popular and democratic aspirations. (Fortunately,
there's the internet and the many independent and alternative
voices one
can find there, and radio shows such as "Democracy
NOW... in exile," that
convinced me I was not alone in my
opinions.) Or even that there may be
another way out of this
quagmire of endless fear and hatred. Up until
Friday, I heard
none of this on the mass TV frenzy, only wrenching
tabloidism,
chauvinistic breast-thumping, and "sober analysis" from old,
white men with blood on their own hands. That is when the
National
Cathedral service was held in DC.
Now, normally, the only thing that
irks me more than politicians
wrapping themselves in the flag is when they
wrap themselves in
religion, or, more accurately, religiosity. For Bush to
call a
"day of prayer" and a national service at noon struck me as just
so much more pandering and ass-covering. And yet, here, and ONLY
here,
was one voice after another calling for love and
forgiveness rather than
hate and vengeance, for justice and
patience rather than retaliation and
haste. Priests, imams,
rabbis, ministers -- even Billy Graham -- invoking
the Bible,
Koran, and quoting saintly men, warning about the descending
spiral of violence and hate, that we must not become the evil we
would
overcome.
Surely Bush, who calls himself a Christian, and claims Jesus
as
his "most influential philosopher," would be swayed by this
consistent call to higher consciousness and righteous action!
Wasn't
that the reason all these persons of the cloth were
invited, to help guide
us AND the Resident of the White House to
the more noble path? Why else were
we being exhorted to resist
hate and embrace forgiveness? Or was this merely
a craven
subterfuge, using more emotionalism and spiritual endorsement to
wrap a burning Bush in a cloak of moral righteousness? What do
YOU
think? (Hint: is Bush walking the path of peace, or taking
the road to war?)
That evening, here in Ellenville, there was to be a candle vigil
at
7 PM. Following the receipt of emails calling for people to
go outside their
house or car at 7 PM (originally Pacific time)
to light a candle, a school
board member and former teacher sent
out emails and flyers urging locals to
meet in the heart of our
village, Liberty Square, AS a community. But was
this going to
be a community coming together in peace and sorrow, or in
anger
and jingoism? What would it mean to bring and wave a flag? Who
was
going to speak and what would they say? Was this going to be
a call to
reflect... or a call to arms?
Minutes before I left the house, I printed
out a copy of
something Martin Luther King Jr. had said that summarized my
concerns:
"The ultimate weakness of violence is that it is a
descending
spiral, begetting the very thing it seeks to destroy. Instead of
diminishing evil, it multiplies it. Through violence you may
murder the
liar, but you cannot murder the lie, nor establish
the truth. Through
violence, you may murder the hater, but you
do not murder hate. In fact,
violence merely increases hate. So
it goes. Returning violence for violence
multiples violence,
adding deeper darkness to a night already devoid of
stars.
Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate
cannot drive out hate; only love can do that."
Between one and two
hundred persons showed up with candles,
flags, ribbons, and wearing
red/white/blue clothes. The school
board member explained why he'd organized
this on the fly, then
introduced the mayor and the town supervisor, who
broached the
line of "taking care of business" and "standing tall"
flag-waving; I fingered the King paragraph in my pocket, ready
to insist
that I be allowed to read it if this kept up.
Fortunately, a black baptist
minister spoke next, and covered
the concerns I (and King) had; for this
speaker only did I
applaud loudly, to show, I hoped, that THIS was what we
should
be standing united FOR. (An invited rabbi couldn't make it as it
was already after sundown and he was conducting services.)
Next, an
American Legion honor guard, in uniforms, brought the
flags up, and taps was
played. "God Bless America" was sung. I
felt a part... and I felt apart. Why
couldn't there ALSO be an
honor guard made up of a fireman, teacher,
paramedic,
minister... representing healing and helping instead of martial
uniformity? Why couldn't we sing "Imagine" by John Lennon, a
song for
EVERYONE, for a world that could "be as one" instead of
just singing more
about being US against THEM?
When we were done, people left their lit
candles around the
fountain and stairs. I talked to a few persons who seemed
to
agree with me about the horrible way this was careening, as if
by
playbook, toward more innocent lives being taken, and a
clueless and
incompetent "leader" taking HIS marching orders
from the military-industrial
complex that bought his
"selection." I KNOW I wasn't the only one who felt
this way, but
I KNEW I wasn't in the majority; most people were willing to
be
manipulated -- letting their emotions be the leash by which they
would agree to support more killing, erosion of civil liberties,
profits
for munitions makers and oil suppliers -- and would
grunt and rally behind
an illegitimate faux prez eager to cover
up a sinking economy and doofus
persona.
Now, with a Republicrat Congress almost unanimously giving this
least-qualified sock-puppet cowboy Resident unprecedented powers
and
money (only one rep, Barbara Lee of Berkeley, dissenting) to
wage
unspecified war against unspecified enemies for an
unspecified time under
the incredibly offensive title of
"Operation Infinite Justice" (to be
changed, it seems, now that
Muslim clerics have pointed out that only GOD
can dispense
infinite justice!), and Bush even calling it a "crusade" --
another remark from the history-challenged Shrub that must be
giving
Muslims everywhere even more reason to be skeptical, if
not downright
defensive -- what is left for us to do but wait
for the other shoes to drop?
Cruise missile shoes. "Smart bomb" shoes. Incendiary shoes.
One
phrase of Dubya's has convinced me that he is not merely a
feeble-minded
Elmer Fudd, but is a fully-certifiable raving
megalomaniac of global
proportions: he has publicly said "we
will rid the world of evildoers!" Even
Superman or Batman
wouldn't have made such an outrageous boast! NO, only
someone
with messianic delusions would make such a claim... and I don't
recall even Jesus making it. The brother of a Brit who died in
the WTC
heard Bush's speech and said "This man should be caged!"
And does this
thief of an election really believe that this
attack was done because
somebody hates and envies our freedom
and democracy? Does anyone think this
AWOL National Guard
fratboy would have the balls to fly into a building for
something HE believed in? Does anyone think that this illiterate
ninny,
who called the residents of Greece "Grecians" and who has
to be muzzled by
his handlers to avoid more such outrages, is
competent to negotiate the
subtle and frightful strategic
minefield before us? (There are, in fact 10
million real mines
IN Afghanistan, 10% of the world's total, many left
behind by a
humiliated and demoralized Soviet Army, forced to return to a
crumbled Soviet empire. Oh, and WE financed and trained the
Afghans who
did that, and Bin Laden is one of them.)
I will not fly or mount the US
flag, because I don't know what
it means anymore to do so; will it be
interpreted to mean the
opposite of what I want it to? I may want it to
stand for being
united in the face of adversity, but won't it be seen as
jingoistic posturing, along with guttural grunts of "USA! USA!"?
I would
rather fly a whole-earth-seen-from-space flag (many,
many hundreds of the
WTC missing were NOT U.S. Americans, but
Brits, Japanese, Chileans,
Canadians, Pakistanis, Germans,
Turks, Israelis, Colombians, and other
nationals), or a picture
of Gandhi or a dove.
I am currently running
for county legislator and know that to
stand up for the cause of
non-violence, justice, democracy, and
ecology (the Green four pillars) may
not be "politic" in a
Wag-the-Dog time of "rallying around our leader,
whoever he is"
and "America under Attack... on Alert... United... Rising!"
But
what can be more important than to resist mindless and pumped-up
leaps over the precipice? Am I the only one who recalls being
lied to
with the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution? THAT phony drum beat
led to hundreds of
thousands of US casualties, and millions of
Vietnamese. Did Desert Storm
restore "democracy" to Kuwait? Or
did we mostly just manage to kill at least
a million innocent
Iraqis, over half being kids? How many Sudanese did we
kill by
bombing a pharmaceutical factory in a vain attempt to torment
Bin Laden?
NONE of this justifies what happened in NYC and DC, but
does
anyone believe that there aren't people who sincerely DO believe
that WE are the greatest purveyors of terrorism, arms sales,
repression,
and death worldwide? Who believe it enough to kill
themselves and others to
make the point? Or was THAT point even
mentioned by the media and pols since
9/11? No, these were
"inhuman madmen," "faceless cowards," "enemies of
humanity." And
thus we can blithely ignore their motivations and the root
causes that LEAD to such actions... or OUR role in maintaining
the
cycles of fear, anger, and hatred. Root out the terrorists
responsible, and
bring them to justice, of course... but root
out the reasons FOR such
actions and apply justice there as
well.
I fear that Prince George
will lead us down an endless, mindless
path: of more Americans killing and
being killed; of having our
rights curtailed; of having LESS security and
LESS freedom.
Fools rush in where wise men fear to tread; I will not follow
an
ignorant and incompetent fool into his delusional "crusade." I
will
point out his folly, and demand that this NOT be done in MY
name... in OUR
name. NOW is not the time to shrink back and let
the yelping dogs of war
keep us from our turn at the public
lectern. As the Talmud says, "Who can
protest and does not, is
an accomplice in the act."
Is it still
possible, even at this late hour, to wage peace? Can
reason and
understanding prevail? Can enough of us become the
living instruments of
peace to stop the ultimate descent into
madness?
(I would be
interested in hearing YOUR thoughts on this matter,
and will place some of
your replies in future posts, with your
permission.)
2) My
brother, Al, sent me his latest "Orlando Weekly" column
last week for me to
edit and tweak:
The chickens have come home to roost. But these birds
had teeth.
And with them, they bit deep into the core of the American
psyche. They had long silver wing spans that sliced through our
prideful
postures and woke us from our cozy somnolence. And they
had claws that
plucked us, dazed and bleeding, out of our myopic
isolation and into a
frightening new world of terror and lost
innocence.
The images of
destruction are endlessly repeated in a slow
motion montage. They segue into
scenes of the weary and
desperate diggers -- hands slowly grubbing through
the wreckage,
hoping without hope to discover an evanescent breath still
lingering beneath the dusty tomb where thousands lay. The story
has a
title now -- "Attack on America" -- and even a musical
soundtrack. It's the
latest miniseries for a nation that is used
to watching history unfold from
the safety of its couches and
dens. Only now, no room is safe.
A
stunned and uncomprehending citizenry wonders how this could
happen. How can
anyone hate us so much to sacrifice so many
lives, including their own, to
further some dim and confusing
political agenda? Having spent decades
satisfying its glut of
recreational pursuits -- gazing only inward... its
attention
span, short... its diets, profligate and unyielding -- it
staggers around in disbelief, like a punch-drunk fighter,
oblivious to
the last fifty years of American repression abroad.
All the brutal
dictators we've propped up, the selfish regimes
we've strengthened -- in
Cuba, Panama, Nicaragua, El Salvador,
Honduras, Haiti, Chile, Vietnam,
Indonesia, the Philippines,
Iran, Saudi Arabia. All the suffering our
leaders have meted out
in our name, or in which they've been complicit -- in
Iraq, the
Sudan, Afghanistan, Somalia, Cambodia, Angola, Algeria, Lebanon,
Palestine. Terror? Surely not us! Why, we believe only in peace
and
democracy. No, my dear American brethren. The sad truth is:
we, too, have
blood on our hands. We've made many enemies on the
farm. The only real
question is -- why have the chickens waited
so long?
But, last week,
they struck back. Make no mistake, there is no
excuse for what these mad
fowl have done. There never can be for
brutality in any form -- whether it's
a vicious attack upon
innocent civilians with flying bombs, or the slow
bleeding to
death of the voiceless and powerless through savage economic and
political policies. But our people have never been known for
thoughtful
or historically-contextual ruminations upon the
complexities of
international relations. We're the Oprah
nation... we're only concerned with
our feelings. And now we
feel angry and we want to lash out.
So,
sound the tocsins of war! Bomb the barnyard! Overrun the hen
house! Root the
chickens out! The old, familiar cants return: us
versus them; good versus
evil; God is on our side. The flags
unfurl. The candles glow. The patriotic
songs are sung. The
aging warriors return to the scene -- arm in arm and
shoulder to
shoulder -- united in rage, clamoring for righteous retribution.
The alarms are rung. The fever grows. An inept and
intellectually-stunted president talks in cliched and
unsophisticated
half-sentences: "They can run... they cannot
hide..."
Ah, but they
can, Mr. President, they can! They've been doing so
all along, and they will
continue to do so. Go ahead... bomb
Afghanistan back to the stone age. It
hasn't very far to go,
anyhow. But they'll turn up somewhere else, you see.
In Germany,
or Canada, or East Africa, or maybe even the small towns of
Florida's golden coasts. Where else will your bombs have to
fall, then?
And they won't be chickens next time, anyway. They'll be
weasels,
burrowing under cities in subways and tunnels, waiting
for rush hour to
unleash their vials of deadly pathogens.
They'll be sharks, swimming
patiently at sea, until the time is
right to poison the coasts with lethal,
toxic chemicals. They'll
be foxes, skipping across the borders at night,
armed with
nuclear devices which they'll calmly detonate beneath the shadow
of the Capitol dome.
No, Mr. President. Put away the tools of war.
They will only sow
more of the same. Haven't hundreds of years of human
misery --
in Ireland, the Middle East, the Balkans -- taught us anything
at all? The cycle of violence is an endless loop. By all means,
locate
the guilty and try to right this horrible wrong. But do
it patiently. Be
restrained. Use only legitimate and appropriate
means.
Remember: if
we want justice, we must practice being just. If we
want peace, we must be
peaceful. If we want help from the
community of nations, we must help the
poor and ignorant out of
their poverty and darkness. There is no "them" and
"us" anymore.
There is only one planet. And the chicken and the eagle have
only one option left in this new and perilous age. In the end,
they must
both become doves. All else is madness.
3) Subject: letter from
grieving parents
Not in our son's name
(letter of parents of son
missing at World Trade Center)
Saturday, Sep 15, 2001 8:35pm
[Phyllis and Orlando Rodriguez's son Greg is one of the Trade
Center
victims. They have asked that people share these letters
this copy of letter
sent to NY Times as widely as possible.]
Not in Our Son's Name
Our son Greg is among the many missing from the World Trade
Center
attack. Since we first heard the news, we have shared
moments of grief,
comfort, hope, despair, fond memories with his
wife, the two families, our
friends and neighbors, his loving
colleagues at Cantor Fitzgerald / ESpeed,
and all the grieving
families that daily meet at the Pierre Hotel.
We see our hurt and anger reflected among everybody we meet. We
cannot pay attention to the daily flow of news about this
disaster. But
we read enough of the news to sense that our
government is heading in the
direction of violent revenge, with
the prospect of sons, daughters, parents,
friends in distant
lands dying, suffering, and nursing further grievances
against
us.
It is not the way to go. It will not avenge our son's
death. Not
in our son's name.
Our son died a victim of an inhuman
ideology. Our actions should
not serve the same purpose. Let us grieve. Let
us reflect and
pray. Let us think about a rational response that brings real
peace and justice to our world. But let us not as a nation add
to the
inhumanity of our times.
Copy of letter to White House:
Dear
President Bush:
Our son is one of the victims of Tuesday's attack on the
World
Trade Center. We read about your response in the last few days
and
about the resolutions from both Houses, giving you undefined
power to
respond to the terror attacks.
Your response to this attach does not
make us feel better about
our son's death. It makes us feel worse.
It
makes us feel that our government is using our son's memory
as a
justification to cause suffering for other sons and parents
in other lands.
It is not the first time that a person in your position has been
given unlimited power and came to regret it.
This is not the time for
empty gestures to make us feel better.
It is not the time to act like
bullies. We urge you to think
about how our government can develop peaceful,
rational
solutions to terrorism, solutions that do not sink us to the
inhuman level of terrorists.
Sincerely,
Phyllis and Orlando
Rodriguez
4) If you have Macromedia Player 5, here is an animation that
puts it simply:
http://www.alternet.org/break_cycle.html
5) There are some press releases from the Green Party of the
United States, the War Resistors League, and some other groups
and
individuals who MUST resist the mad dash to war, on
principle. I will post
some of these in the next few postings.
Steve Krulick
s@krulick.com
http://krulick.com
845-647-8809
Ellenville NY 12428-130727
http://wawarsinggreens.org
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/WawarsingGreens
http://ulstergreens.org
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/GreenActivity_UlsterCounty
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/UlsterNYgreens
http://dem101.org
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Democracy101
--------------------------
"Nothing can stop
the power of
an informed citizenry
when it is
empowered, organized, and
motivated." (Ralph Nader)
--------------------------