Greenpeace China announced
on Wednesday that genetically modified
rice "appears to have been planted and sold illegally in China for
the last two years" according to its findings in central China's
Hubei Province.
More alarmingly, two of the samples tested positive as Bt rice,
genetically engineered to contain an inbuilt toxin.
Agricultural experts and Ministry of Agriculture officials
immediately denied the Greenpeace claims and cited China's own
"technical standards" for testing GM products.
But their answers do not lessen the public's worries over the
safety of GM rice. The Greenpeace findings have sounded a warning
bell.
Extra attention and caution is needed as far as GM rice is
concerned.
Sales of GM rice seeds are strictly prohibited in China by
legally-binding regulations and no GM rice has ever been approved
for human consumption.
Since July 1996,
the Ministry of Agriculture has promulgated a
series of related regulations to provide safeguards for the
research, including laboratory and field experiments, transportation
and marketing of GM farm products.
So far, only GM cotton has been widely introduced into the fields
of China. Some brands of GM beans, mostly from the United States,
have been cleared for entry into cooking oil processing plants.
Still an un-named Agriculture Ministry official admitted that GM
rice has been planted on a limited scale, according to China Daily's
report yesterday.
Such a fact alone should make the public become more vigilant
about GM rice.
Rice is the most important staple crop in the world. More than
half of Chinese and most of all the people in Southeast and South
Asia rely on it for calories and protein. Rice flour and gruel
constitute an important part of the diet for babies and the elderly
in those countries.
People in favour of enhanced GM rice research argue that GM rice
offers high yields and improved nutritional content to better feed
the rice-eating population.
Some of them even go as far as claiming that those who call for
extreme caution are anti-science. They say there is no known
publicly available environmental or human food safety evaluations
for any GM rice that claims it does harm.
But they may be being too smug about their "science." Other
scientists have already pointed out the potential adverse effects of
GM rice, especially Bt rice, on the environment and health.
For instance, it may affect butterflies and moths, infect weeds,
and help insects resistant to the introduced toxin grow stronger. It
could also contaminate natural genetic resources and affect
long-term soil health.
Studies have shown GM maize and corn may already have led to
serious environmental and health consequences and could have
contaminated more natural seedlings.
Researchers in Mexico reported to a United Nations' bio-safety
conference that nearly half of the maize samples collected from
farming communities far from urban centres tested positive for
transgenic proteins.
Clearly GM maize has in some way disrupted the local
bio-diversity of traditional maize.
Meanwhile, the public must not forget that the United States had
to recall one type of GM corn worth US$1 billion because it
contained the Bt toxin that kills pests but may also cause
allergenic reactions in humans, according to Greenpeace.
Such effects as those could also apply to GM rice, even as the
public waits for the promised further investigation from Hubei
provincial government to see if this is already happening.
Humankind has caused tremendous damages to the environment, our
own health and bio-diversity as a result of some initial "scientific
achievements."
We should learn from our past mistakes while pushing forward such
advances as GM rice, before it is too late to make amends.